LogFAQs > #971672246

LurkerFAQs, Active DB, DB1, DB2, DB3, DB4, DB5, DB6, DB7, DB8, DB9, DB10, Database 11 ( 12.2022-11.2023 ), DB12, Clear

Topic List	Page List: 1
Topic	Paper Mario Mafia Topic 10 - Thinner Mario, Bigger Adventure!
EDumey 02/19/23 1:18:24 PM #48:	Peace___Frog posted... Day 1 - Kirby didn't vote for Ben, but he was on him consistently for being off. You rushed to Ben's defense. Where did I rush to Ben's defense. I had him in my "lurking under the radar list" and pretty sure I never read him as town or defended him during that day. I certainly didn't have a read on him because he didn't post much. Peace___Frog posted... Day 2 - you both voted for Ben then unvoted him, but again, Kirby was on ben's case so much harder than you were. You're right that Kirby went much harder on Ben than me. I stated early this day that the early adoption of going after Ben is the strongest thing in Kirby's favor, so I'll agree with you there. This doesn't discount the idea of Kirby just deciding to bus Ben though. Peace___Frog posted... Day 3 - Kirby buried Ben and was on him a lot. You were not on ben at all. Read intent, and not just the votals. I had Ben on my proposed scum teams the ENTIRE day, and multiple times referred to him as a strong possibility of being scum. It's also one of the reasons why I continued onto Ulti today, because I had already made those conclusions the prior day. Are you going to say I'm not on Red at all today just because I'm not putting him at -2 right now before the day ends? I understand now at least that your entire analysis is just based on Kirby's voting record and being on Ben, while when I'm thinking of "day play" I'm actually trying to evaluate motivations and scum hunting. Not saying you're wrong to take that line! But that explains why I have such a strongly different reaction to Kirby than you. --- my links broke. :( <cite>EDumey posted [p:971672246] in Paper Mari... [t:80353533]...</cite> <quote>Peace___Frog posted... </cite><quote>Day 1 - Kirby didn't vote for Ben, but he was on him consistently for being off. You rushed to Ben's defense.</quote>Where did I rush to Ben's defense. I had him in my "lurking under the radar list" and pretty sure I never read him as town or defended him during that day. I certainly didn't have a read on him because he didn't post much.Peace___Frog posted... </cite><quote>Day 2 - you both voted for Ben then unvoted him, but again, Kirby was on ben's case so much harder than you were.</quote>You're right that Kirby went much harder on Ben than me. I stated early this day that the early adoption of going after Ben is the strongest thing in Kirby's favor, so I'll agree with you there. This doesn't discount the idea of Kirby just deciding to bus Ben though.Peace___Frog posted... </cite><quote>Day 3 - Kirby buried Ben and was on him a lot. You were not on ben at all.</quote>Read intent, and not just the votals. I had Ben on my proposed scum teams the ENTIRE day, and multiple times referred to him as a strong possibility of being scum. It's also one of the reasons why I continued onto Ulti today, because I had already made those conclusions the prior day.Are you going to say I'm not on Red at all today just because I'm not putting him at -2 right now before the day ends?I understand now at least that your entire analysis is just based on Kirby's voting record and being on Ben, while when I'm thinking of "day play" I'm actually trying to evaluate motivations and scum hunting. Not saying you're wrong to take that line! But that explains why I have such a strongly different reaction to Kirby than you. --- my links broke. :(</quote> ... Copied to Clipboard!
Topic List	Page List: 1