LogFAQs > #971670818

Han, sorry, can you please remind me who you targeted n1? Or your power wasn't active then or something?

If you honestly want me to consider 3+1 remaining, then one possibility is Dumey + you and ctes with red as indy. I find this very unlikely but it's a possibility.

Most realistically at this time, I think it's Dumey+red with one remaining in Ulti or hb.

However, Plum hasn't had an incredible game and could be skating by since you and i declared him as town d2. This could check out with scum avoiding you entirely day 1 in order to put suspicion on you, since plum was also with sbell in making sure people don't go after you.

Ulti is... Ulti. He's been nothing if not consistently inconsistent.

Hb i thought was town early on but we all know how my track record is. I do not think it is both Ulti and hb, but I keep going back and forth here. Hb has been very reserved and in recent memory has only really stood out when i called him chummy with Sbell due to one joke post he made on d1. Neither player has really done anything that make me think they are town.

I'm going to put it out there preemptively here for myself, I think that I've had a pretty bad game. I've been overly paranoid, latched hard onto my own out of the box ideas and had difficulty getting out of them, and really struggled overall. I can understand why you think I might be scummy.

But I want to, in my defense, point to how many times I wanted to vote sbell on day 1. You were the one who told me no on that, han. And still I kept bringing it up.
Then for the d1 lynch, me being scum depends on at least one of you, hb, and plum being scum, if not two. That would have been an unbelievably risky play and I do not have the guts that others do for something like that. I am especially cowardly when I have something to hide.

And when Ben was calling Dumey town on day 2 for the level of effort that he was putting in, I tried to be the voice of reason about Dumey. He puts in work regardless of alignment. I notice you didn't back me up on that despite just letting in a game with him where he led the game in posts on the last day, and was close to the top on earlier days. I didn't outright call him scum because i don't know how to read the man, but i did try to remind everybody that his earnestness is not necessarily a town trait.

I've said it in the last topic but if Kirby is scum then he deserves a medal and his first victory. He is not in my poe whatsoever.

So, in summary:
Dumey & red both anti-town, both got to go.
Hb/ulti - one of them is very probably scum. Could be both if red is truly indie or Dumey is town.

Plum - if somehow Dumey is town and hb/ulti are not both scum, then plum would remain in my poe.
Han/ctes - can be scum in the situation where Dumey, hb, and Ulti are all town and red is either indie or town (unlikely)

Kirby - town