LogFAQs > #971580086

I actually just read back, and I'm sorry, but you don't have a good argument and it's honestly baffling that you call Ben "confirmed Town" for a role flip that he doesn't have anything to do with.

Here's a hypothetical for you:

If somebody else came forward and offered a similar role to Ben's, do you still think he's confirmed? A better role?

Your idea that Ben's claim interacts with Mario role is just wrong. It requires two claims and free offering of information to go off. And it'd be pretty dumb to have a role that's "you have a like 15% chance to find a Star Spirit at random. Otherwise, you have shit. Also, without being told, you should know it's important to offer this information up to the town so that a role you don't know exists can get multiple jumps in a row."

I don't think that's good design. In the slightest.