LogFAQs > #971539296

EDumey posted...

One thing I found curious is that in Kirby's list of reads in 4.266, he separated Red from the other "nebulous" low activity players. This could be meaningless, but just wanted to note it.

Everyone that I didn't say was town or scum was a neutral read, sans Sultan who I have as town leaning, but it's not a strong town lean. But he's probably my highest town read on the list of neutral reads.

But to elaborate, they're all neutral reads but varying degrees of neutral, put into a more meme-y format. Red is "Present" because he hasn't said much of anything, but Red never says anything. That's not a defense, but it's also not an attack on Red. He's a tough nut to crack if he barely interacts with anyone.

Ulti is "White Noise" because I've largely been ignoring his posts since they're extremely vocal and confident reads from a dude that has not caught up with the game yet has full confidence in his reads.

You and Death are in "Vanguards of the Neutral Reads Frontline" because I've gone back and forth on you two repeatedly. You guys aren't hiding in the shadows, and yet I can't get a solid grasp on your alignments.

And then Ctes, JC, and Hb are "Lost in the Sea of Nebulous Idkness" because I have no solid read on those folks, nor have they really done anything to make much of an impression on me. I've agreed with most of Ctes's posts, but like Han said, Ctes has felt like mostly words and not much action. JC I'm starting to lean town on just because his explanations seem a little too uncanny to be fake scum logic. And then Hb I initially thought was town because of his botched crusade on Sultan, but he really hasn't done much afterward. I guess he was critical at overtime for saying he'd vote Peaf... and then not doing it, allowing Plum to unvote and break the tie?

Anyway, speaking of Ulti being white noise...

UltimaterializerX posted...

Han is probably town.
Death is probably town.
Kirby is probably town.
Plum is probably town.
I don't feel too great about Sultan.

Don't think to hard about any of the explained here, they're not hard reads then. It's all mostly a mix of gut feel and knowledge of usual play.

The fact that so little have pinged me wrongly makes me think most scum are a combination of good players and people that haven't been around much yet."

I like this ctes post. Huge town points. I agree with most of those reads, mainly the Sultan one.

???????
Ulti was out here calling me scum, and now he's agreeing with Ctes that I'm town? Without any elaboration at all?

I am going to be peeved if we lose this game because a town Ulti decides to lynch Plum at the last second or something because he hasn't been reading the game.