LogFAQs > #970591252

Yeah it was absolutely winnable with town

There are just two fundamental issues with the setup.

1. Abilities ending day without a lynch are pretty much bad. Mayor works because you still have lynch data. A day executioner that was usable only after the lynch was locked in, like a mayor with a kill... possibly usable. But having that actual lynch take place is important to give solving material.
2. With bad luck the game can end on day 3 with no lynches taking place. A setup that can do this, even if that's unlikely, is not well designed.

I think the balance was mostly fine. It's just those two issues are a very big deal.

Make scum executioner work like mayor timing, make desperado not end day, and make the weak doctor a standard doctor or some form of weak protection that can't kill itself like a bulletproof or jack and I think the setup is good, perhaps even weighted towards town.