LogFAQs > #968618799

Underleveled posted...

It doesn't even surprise me a little bit that James was awful. I wouldn't have Domenick and David in my list of people I wouldn't want to see again though. Domenick was entertaining enough on Ghost Island (granted, mostly by virtue of being one of the only electric players/personalities in an extremely lifeless cast) and David was at least a very nice, funny guy, even if he is a bit of a trainwreck of a BB player (a lot of which isn't his fault... I think he ends up in unwinnable scenarios a lot).

I don't hate Domenick in Ghost Island (because, as you said, that season is so supremely lifeless), but he's very much in the vein of "over-strategic gamebot". He was absolutely cast to be like a diet Tony...and I just didn't want to see that on another show. As for David, we'd gotten two seasons of him at that point, and I just didn't feel like I needed to see him again. It's not that he's bad...I just don't know if he was ever going to make a big contribution to the show.