LogFAQs > #967038307

Please note that I really have neglected Town this game and i'm sorry. I'd say that the early replace and the effort i put into catching the BCT/Plum player spot, albeit wrong, took the wind out of my sails and then I work and family just got busy. No excuses. Not looking for emotional "oh he must be town" responses based on this statement. I just want to preface why I have such few opinions below:

1. Ben - fake Miller claim, his reasoning behind it is sound, I can't argue that by claiming it he would essentially be telling Town Investigative Roles to stay away, however he also lured a Doc Save on Night 1 which could also have been his entire purpose. Unfortunate that Isquen believed said claim and decided to save you. I've been up and down on Ben this game, i'd say leans more scum at this point.

2. Corrik - What is there to say. I have a hard time fingering him as Scum. I don't like what he has to say. I know for a fact that he's lying about a Scum scan on me. Corrik has an extremely abrasive approach to Mafia. He manages to say a lot while saying very little and still insulting everyone. Its a wonder why he even plays but thats besides the point. Whats his gambit here? Has he just convinced himself that I have to be scum based on his read? Well we all know gut reads can be wrong. I do not lynch Corrik here, as much as i'd love to just remove him from the game, he is still likely Town. I jsut dont see Scum Corrik going to this extreme.

3. ctes - I have zero read. I should do an ISO

4. Death - I tend to read death well most of the time. I like to say I can nail when he's town but that was shattered from his last scum game. an ISO of death would be prudent, but he's not on my must lynch now.

5. IGCD - Claims BG and to have protected Han twice. I can agree with the choice. I was feeling good about Han from the start. The inability to block the Poison sucks but I guess that wouldn't normally happen anyway. It starts to stack up the Protection though. Doc, Backup (could be doc), Janitor (doc), Taunter (reverse bg). Thats just what is currently known to us all.

6. Han - probably scum

7. HB - The 1 action Roleblocker who also targeted Han... Less likely to believe this. But role meta isn't a fair shake. ISO of HB is needed.

8. Obellisk - Town. Worthless town, but town.

9. red13n - I've noticed very little from red while reading here and there. Is there anything that i should know that would make me want to say "oh he's totally town?" Lopen involved him in his Claim but that doesn't really mean a whole lot.

10. Sultan - Confirmed Executioner of Mafia Godfather.

11. Ulti - Another day 1 town read for me. His play was more like what i've seen (and learned) from his town games recently. I dont really know what to make of the princess claim thing and we insta winning by day 4. I'm sure whatever he actually is, his power activates by then if he's alive and its probably a goodie. (ie, Lea didn't activate till Day 3).

I'm working in a pool of:
HB
Ben
ctes
igcd

and to lesser extent:
death
red
ulti
corrik

I realize I have both HB and igcd in my pool. its contradictory. There is just a lot of protection floating around but with Role Madness and the fact that Sultan could have killed himself and another town with that gun. Maybe all this protection is warranted.

I need to start doing some work now. I am around.