Without question a Top 4 Metroidvania in my book. I need to let it sink in before I decide whether it's better than SotN, Super, and Dread, but Hollow Knight was incredible and edges out Blasphemous as my favorite indie.
- HK has the best exploration of any Metroidvania I've played. Whereas most games in the genre encourage you to "beat" an area then return later for bonuses/powerups, HK sends you through areas you're not equipped to explore (the jellyfish section) or not equipped to complete (City of Tears) and creates this "setup/payoff" style of exploration. I love it.
- I did encounter pacing issues because of not having the slightest hint where the next necessary powerup might be. There were times I went 2+ hours trying to find something hidden in an obscure section of the map that I overlooked. That said, when I did finally discover where I needed to go, it was intensely rewarding.
- I'm amazed that a Metroidvania map of this size never felt bloated or like it was trying too hard. I beat the game (and some side content) in 27 hours. That's double the length of most long Metroidvanias, yet HK never felt like a slog. Impressive.
- That said, more Stag Stations/warp points would've been nice.
- I'm not a fan of sticking save points 1-2 minutes away from a boss. I hate this game design choice in Soulsborne games and I hate it here too. At least the one-way teleport spell takes the sting out of it.
- The Final Boss
was a massive disappointment. I beat the Traitor Lord prior to attempting The Hollow Knight and found Traitor Lord to be a more intense, exciting battle. The Hollow Knight by comparison felt like a cakewalk remix of that fight. - Ending was
grim and cool with the knight sacrificing himself to protect/preserve the world of Hollownest (or at least that's how I interpreted it). The lore in this game is fantastic, and simple hubs like Dirtmouth and City of Tears contribute so much to the worldbuilding and atmosphere that it's mind-boggling. - Greenpath has S-Tier music: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=fWquuWkHVP4