LogFAQs > #965974499

PunishedBen posted...

So here's the thing, I think Kirby is town. Or at least had the purest intentions at the end of day 1 of anyone voting for Han.

The order of events was -

Kirby tried to save me and voted for Red

He then later voted for Plum after I switched to Plum, again to make to Plum the majority over me. Good look for Kirby

Kirby votes Han. Again, to save me.

All three votes were consistent with protecting a townie from lynch. He didnt just vote Han but was also content to kill Red or Plum once me or Sheep moved to one of them. So he does not look like he was trying to protect a specific scum member. Isolate his posts at the end of day and it tracks. Also I liked Post #151 of Kirby's. Sounds genuine

Really think Kirby was the most town of the people on Han's lynch

I am incredibly sleep deprived and Ben just made my long post better than I did. I am just gonna sleep so I can functionally play the game tomorrow.

Kirby321 posted...

Sheep, why did you unvote Plum just to vote for him again?

Honestly? I panicked and wanted to be able to change my vote to save Ben, and was considering trying to be a hero by joining Ulti on Han. Then the tiny little rational nugget of my brain reminded me that Plum was still probably scum and Han wouldn't get lynched D1 anyway so I should just stick with Plum and hope everyone went back on him.

I genuinely like the Kirby explanation. I noticed when I was rereading that he felt very panicky during the EoD, and I think it's very close to my own thought process. I'm very glad that he mentioned he was very jumpy about the Ben lynch, because I don't see any other good explanation which doesn't involve a ton of EoD nervousness. Some of it tripped me up a bit because Kirby has seemed remarkably calm at times in the two games I've watched him in, even in an F3 scenario, but I'm not sure if it feels different this time because I'm actually in the situation to empathise with how nuts it is rather than stuck on the sidelines.

Also, I would rather not meta late posts. I have been burned by that before, and it feels kinda gross to point to stuff that is actively against the rules of the game to prove a point.

Also also, I'm sorry but Han voting Ben was horrid at the time. The dude was so much more town-seeming than Han and I was very much willing to jump ship onto him if it meant keeping Ben alive.