Kirby321 posted... See, Red is giving me the same vibes as in Sir Chris Mafia, where I was 90% sure he was scum until my role told me that he was actually not scum. Day 1 Red just naturally pings scum, I guess?
Ugh, I'm feeling the same way I did whenever I pushed against Chris's lynch targets from last game. My head says, "Vote for Red. Lea and Han clearly see something that you don't, and if Plum is telling the truth, you just lost a valuable role." But my gut says, "Plum is lying. His behavior has been all over the place, and Hider alongside Invisible seems like overkill in this setup."
Has IGCD posted recently? He said that he feels like the attacks on Plum have been cyclical, where one person's attack on Plum led to another person justifying it with their own attack. I asked him if Plum flips town, who would be the most likely scum out of the people involved in those attacks on him.
My immediate thought after reading back is... Ulti. I liked Ulti's posts because he made good arguments against Plum, I felt. But I feel like (especially in last game) town usually gets mislynched not because they played poorly, but because someone else was controlling the narrative. And I feel like that would be fitting for Ulti if Plum flips town.
So... screw it. I'm going with my gut
Okay, I was gonna rail on Kirby for his lack of analysis a bit more but I actually really like this post!
...which in turn is making me paranoid that I am horribly wrong on Plum and Kirby's covering for Red aaaa
I am surprised people are coming on Plum at this stage and although I feel like Plum is more likely to be scum this post has me second-guessing and I can't put my finger on why