LogFAQs > #965947859

Kirby321 posted...

I very much want to vote Plum, but I'm naturally hesitant given how wrong I was about Tidus in Sir Chris Mafia and Ulti in Star Wars/Pokmon Mafia, both of who were uncountered town power that I was convinced were scum until they flipped. I'm wary about that.

Otherwise, if we're going by roles, lynching the Invisible is the safer option if we don't believe Plum and Lea are both telling the truth. Problem with that is 1) nobody seems to agree with me, so it's probably a stupid idea and 2) I'm not particularly keen on either Plum or Lea being town, but I'd more willing to believe Lea's claim than Plum's, so even I don't think the "safe" option is the smartest choice here.

The easy answer is to say Red, but again, I'd like to hear something back from him. I don't think anything about him struck me as particularly odd, but everyone else seems to think he's the second-best choice.

MZero I am fairly confident is Town. Tidus and Ben both seem to be playing as normal, too. IGCD is acting like his usual town-self I feel, and nothing about your posts have pinged me with weird logic like they did last game, Sheep. chang and Death also didn't seem out of the ordinary, either.

Out of principle, I refuse to lynch BCT or DYL today since it seems they haven't played in a while.

I guess I don't really have any solid reads on Han, Ulti, or Sbell. I mean, I seem to have a tendency to think Han is scum, but I think it's just his posting style that gives me those false flags. Ulti I don't think I remember much from him other than the whole Ben/Lea thing. And Sbell... I don't remember anything from him at all, really.

Hmm... Perhaps I should do a quick review of the day. Really, I'd like to vote for Plum, but I'd also hate to get burned again for lynching the uncountered, claimed power.

I'm gonna try to address a few things here, although I've realised with little time left I should keep this brief. First, why the wariness of Lea? You like her claim, I think she's had a clean game so far (though you may disagree), and as I've mentioned a few times before, this is leagues above last game for her.

Second, are less active players entirely off the table for you? Is this a consistent thing for your D1s, or is there something particular about this game? I'm curious, because I don't think there's many great options besides the less active players, especially if Plum is off the table.

Third... I like your walls, generally, but this one feels lacking. I know you're a very analytical person, and it's missing that streak which I would expect after two games of watching you as town. I know this is a difficult situation, but this is wishy-washy stuff and lacking for this point in the day. I'm willing to give you the benefit of the doubt with a busy weekend for now, but I am concerned and we may be having words tomorrow. If I die tonight (which I think is fairly likely), I would ask that y'all take a look at Kirby. Ben shall be my messenger from beyond the grave.

PunishedBen posted...

Sure, I'll let Death be your favourite as long as I'm your favorite

Everyone in B8 Mafia is my favourite! But especially you and Death.

masterplum posted...

My only concern with Red is I don't remember him contributing much as town last game.

Disagree. He had low activity but a few very good posts in D1 both the last two games. I had him as basically confirmed town by the time I joined D2 in Kingmaker. This does not feel like the same Red.