LogFAQs > #965709249

Chris, if you are the final scum, then this have been a master play from your side and I will take my hat off in defeat, but I don't believe this is the case.

Kirby's best defense for a while was watching Ulti night 2 and Ulti not dying until night 6. This argument here was that it would have been a bad play by scum, but... why couldn't it be? It wasn't even bad when it came down to it, they managed to not kill the people Ulti wanted to protect.

Second was MZero's Doppelganger role explained what would happen in case of watcher. But it also explained tracker and cop, they're not there either. I talked a bit about this the past two days as well, I don't see why it would be so unlikely, especially compared to two godfathers.

I made a post about a Darthmanitan Vader theory yesterday and no one even responded to it. I want to go back to plum's final point before getting shot seemingly very randomly. There's no way Anakin Skywalker is a town's role. He was having none of what Kirby said at the very end of day 3 and he's the one to die. He was on to something then. That gladiate stunt was always extremely weird. Chang was already dying and Kirby still gladiated, arguing that we wouldn't be lycnhing Arti despite saying that Arti might as well be the scum. That was such a weird move. Plum feared he gained something from winning his gladiator match and the fact that the play was so weird was what made me speculate that prequel trilogy Darmanakin switched sides doing that. Or maybe had to do it at some certain point, idk. People argued back then that chang being town and Kirby being scum was extremely unlikely, but if Kirby got something from winning it's a lot less weird. Ultimately, it's no longer important if he was at some point town or whatever. I just think Anakin Skywalker starting as town and later becomming Darth Vader would be an extremely cool role and Darmanitan can somewhat work with both names.

I've had Kirby on the radar a bit constantly, but he has managed to set up some things that made it seem unlikely, but now it's him or Chris. A lot of his posts early on seemed to be making points that actually weren't points. Posts like "One could argue the play was to let Ben die in place of Sheep due to their roles (useless Neighborizer versus useful Tracker). This would assume that scum didn't know about the role switch." It's wront. It doesn't assume that in the slightest. Redirector is a great role, poisoner sure is too! Maybe this was even before they realized just how good poison is.

I'm not 100% certain that Chris isn't the final scum just because he's good enough to pull this off, but it's 99% or so and poison not being used is among the many things that makes it less likely.

Once being in a position more or less confirmed Kirby began having less of these long posts of little effort and have just been going with the flow more or less. I'm willing to dig more into this, but it'll be after a good night's sleep, I must say. Scum knew they had a player somewhat safe and could stroll like this so less effort was needed.