LogFAQs > #964860106

I think the biggest reason that this is so obviously a sham is that she's able to be in the same room as him and look him in the eye. If she was abused as horrifyingly as she is describing, she would not want to be within 100 feet of him. The fact that she wanted to reconcile so quickly after filing for a restraining order is telling on its own.

To recap:
-She was brutally beaten several times, yet didn't need to go to the hospital any of them
-There is photographic evidence of her looking healthy the day after each of the "major" incidents
-People who she claims would corroborate her aren't going to testify, which usually means they'll tell something that contradicts her (we'll have to see what this makeup girl says, but makeup can't hide swelling)
-All her "evidence" seems staged, partially cleaned up, or seems so banal to everyone except her
-Embellished details like "MARILYN MANSON MUSIC" make me think I'm reading an "Am I the asshole?" post.
-Her stories are exactly the opposite of Johnny's side and make her look like an innocent victim, but... the recording exists.

...yeah, it's pretty clear that she's mental.