LogFAQs > #962986970

Conceptually, they're both great. In the films, Maul is more interesting just because Dooku never feels like he's that impressive. Maul has the speed and kinetic movement that makes him feel capable of fighting two Jedi at once, whereas Dooku has kinda slow, sweeping movements that seem like a half-decent Jedi should be able to find the opening.

I get that Christopher Lee was like...80++ years old when episode II was made, but still, he looked a little feeble in his fight scenes and we were mostly left to trust that he was just uber powerful with the force and that's why he wasn't easily beaten by Obi-Wan and Anakin together.

In the expanded/cartoon content, they're both portrayed better, but between the two I think it does way more favors for Dooku than Maul. So I voted Dooku.