You know, in hindsight, I think I would have rather seen Brett than Tyler if we had to get one.
At least Brett has the POTENTIAL to be interesting because he is a shit-stirrer, even if I loathed him the first time around. Tyler I don't see being anything other than a level-headed challenge dominator. To put it in terms of Survivor archetypes, Brett is the Trickster (Fairplay, Tyson, etc) type and Tyler is the Amazing Ace (Ozzy, Malcolm, Joe A, etc) archetype that rarely offers anything new the second time around.