LogFAQs > #931646108

Tallying taking awhile so I'll share what has won over the years that I still have records for!

2011: (10 Voters)
1.Arkham City
2.Saints Row The Third
3.Portal 2

2012: (15 Voters)
1.Halo 4
2.Asuras Wrath
3.Borderlands 2
4.The Walking Dead S1
5.Sleeping Dogs
6.Final Fantasy XIII-2
7.Journey
8.Call of Duty: Black Ops 2
9.PS All Stars
10.Fez

2013 (14 Voters)
1.GTAV
2.Pokemon X/Y
3.The Last of US
4.Bioshock infinite
5.Tomb Raider
6.AC New leaf
7.AC4
8.Beyond Two Souls
9.FE Awakening
10.Saints Row IV

2014 (17 Voters)
1.South Park Stick of Truth
2.Mario Kart 8
3.Smash Wii U
4.The Wolf Among Us
5.Destiny
6.Shadows of Mordor
7.Shovel Knight
8.Dragon Age Inquisition
9.Hearthstone
10.The Evil Within

2015 (16 Voters)
1.Fallout 4
2.Metal Gear Solid V
3.Bloodborne
4.Undertale
5.Life is Strange
6.Halo 5
7.Super Mario Maker
8.Rise of the Tomb Raider
9.Batman:Arkham Knight
10.Witcher 3

2016 (15 Voters)
1.Overwatch
2.Final Fantasy XV
3.Dark Souls 3
4.Dragon Quest VII
5.Titanfall 2
6.Gears of War 4
7.Digimon Story Cyber Sleuth
8.World of Final Fantasy
9.DOOM
10.Tokyo Mirage Sessions #FE

2017 (13 Voters)
1.The Legend of Zelda: Breath of the Wild
2.Persona 5
3.Super Mario Odyssey
4.Resident Evil 7
5.Nier Automata
6.Cuphead
7.Horizon Zero Dawn
8.Sonic Mania
9.Prey
10.Injustice 2

2018 (10 Voters)
1.Spiderman
2.God of War
3.Smash Ultimate
4.Shadow of the Tomb Raider
5.Monster Hunter World
6.Dragon Quest 11
7.Detroit Become Human
8.Astro Bot
9.Forza Horizon 4
10.Yakuza Kiwami 2


---

XBL/PSN/:StingX2
Switch: 0675-3724-0313