LogFAQs > #929899473

Cruddy_horse posted...

I wouldn't replay the parts of TWD that already did, you really see how much the games fall apart on repeat plays.

If it's been a while since you played and you've mostly forgotten your choices/the story, and you replay picking mostly the same choices (mainly to just maintain continuity of choices for future episodes), you're not really seeing the seams too badly.

It's really only if you finish a playthrough and then immediately go back and make different choices to see how things are different that you start to realize how many of your choices were kind of pointless. But most players don't DO that (statistically, just based on trophy/achievement data, it seems like most players these days don't even finish games once, let alone multiple times).

Though I will say some Telltale games are worse than others when it comes to that sort of thing. Tales from the Borderlands had at least two major choices that change the story pretty significantly in parts (comparing my playthough to one my nephew did, there were some pretty major differences in a couple places). But I know the Batman games felt extremely railroady for some of the major choices, where no matter what you picked the outcome was more or less the same regardless (and from what I know, the Walking Dead games tend to be the same way).
---

"Wall of Text'D!" --- oldskoolplayr76
"POwned again." --- blight family