LogFAQs > #929493519

Lee Shion - Aurora: 8, maybe an 8.5. There's a lot to like about the song; it's pretty, it hits about the right amount of sadness ("I'm sinking away into a deep dark emptiness" is rather Duvet-esque in its bluntness), but I don't connect with this quite as much as I did with Ordinary (or Duvet, or Baby Bird). Still a good song that would be assured a decent placement, but not likely to win any contests.

Else - To Your City: 6, maybe 7. I like her voice, the underwater gimmick, the shark, and the video (puppets!) but I'm not fully drawn into the music. Having trouble finding any trace of the lyrics; not a dealbreaker, but they'd probably help a song like this that I'm not fully connecting with based only on the music itself.

Vtubermana: 2 or 3. She's got a nice design, but the song really isn't my type of thing. I don't usually like non-lyric vocalizations and while I can somewhat appreciate how different the song is from every other one you've submitted, it's...just not for me, sorry.

Virtual Butler Cecilia - Disco Necropolis: 1. It's like the last song, only more than twice as long and about half as good.

Cecilia (second link) - Probably a 1 or a 2 too.

Virtual Butler Cecilia - Luna Ascension: Easily the best of the three, but acapella still rarely works for me... leaning towards a 4 here?

Suntory Nomu & YuNi - That's Why I Gave Up on Music: Probably a 5, maybe a 6. It's a great video and a good story, but I don't feel any connection with Nomu at all--and having listened to the original version, I at least feel something from Yorushika, so I feel comfortable saying I just don't like Nomu. The original is a 6, maybe a 6.Something...this one feels like a step below it, but I could see myself giving it the same score anyway.

Suntory Nomu Second Link - 3; it was fine, but inspired no feeling or any interest in typing anything, nor did it leave any lasting impression. It played for a minute and was quickly forgotten.

Fuji Aoi - Get Wild: Leaning towards something like 4.8; it's close to an average score of 5, but I don't really feel like giving it the full 5 points. It's fine, but...I dunno. Chorus repeats a bit too often?

Milky Queen - ECHO: 7 or 8; it's good and I enjoy hearing another version of this song, but I'm still partial to Ruri's version (which I think I'm going to retroactively increase to 9 points, after going back and listening to it again I like Ruri's ECHO even more than I thought I did) her voice feels more artificial and I have an easier time connecting with her version of the song. Of course, Ruri's has the advantage of being the version I heard first, so it's possible Milky Queen's is just under a natural disadvantage...

RukiRoki - Lucky: 6; they're adorable, but the song is a bit too happy for me right now.

RukiRoki Second Song: 6; they're still adorable and the song is still too happy.



And I need a break here... will try to get a few more songs in before I go to sleep tonight, if possible.
---

A not very secret alt account for when Raetsel wants to be a pony