LogFAQs > #922944937

turbopuns3 posted...

@Corrik7
@UltimaterializerX
@red13n
@Leafeon13N

Serious, important question.

Let's pretend that all of you are town.

Who is scum then?

I am to assume that all of these three are town? Or just I am town in this scenario?

If all 3 are town, 5tar and Puns or 5tar and Panthera.

If just me. I already stated who I think.

I can't see any play the entire game where Ulti has acted as town would. The mere comment that makes me think Ulti could be town was eaeds comment to him based on his behavior.

I can see an argument red is town just based on the fact that Han was rated higher than him and they thought scare was cop. Then when cop was revealed and tracker they had to deal with scanners / doctor hunt. So they never got to red.

But, who did scum shoot night 2. Death says IGCD and I think that is quite plausible.

But, let's say Ulti is Town Vanilla. Scum knows town IGCD supposedly tracked town Ulti to the night kill.

Wouldn't they think Ulti was Doctor then? And have to have shot Ulti last night? I am unsure actually why Ulti never even put forward this argument. That pez saved him cuz with Tom's flip Ulti if tracked to scare was the doctor if town. (Tho pez's role and doctor don't really make sense together, but it would be what SCUM would be thinking if they knew IGCD was town and he said he tracked Ulti there?)

Problem is, I don't think Pez would have saved Ulti even with Tom's flip. The roles can't really exist together. But, again, scum didn't know pez's role. Ulti never even considered this defense at all. Because I think Ulti is just flailing about and isn't actually thinking out the game. Nor red.

Now let's say Ulti is scum and IGCD is town. Scum knows IGCD is lying. So why would they shoot IGCD at night? So who would scum have shot night 2? Me who hinted at power? Red? Surely not IGCD if Ulti is scum who they know is lying. Right?

This is shit that town Red would be all over trying to figure out.

However, he has not advanced a single argument why Ulti is Town and has never acknowledged a single argument that Ulti is by far the most likely to be scum. He has handwaved any and all evidence to the contrary or ignored it.
---

Xbox Live User Name - Corrik
Currently playing: Kingdom Hearts 3