LogFAQs > #894820175

Ultima_Dragoon posted...

Replay is so much better than no replay to me. Are you guys forgetting the dark days of no replay? Where we would all be thinking, "We lost the game because of that call...if only they could go back and see what really happened".

But we still think that all the time even with replay.

Another thing that disappoints me is that it often takes away exciting plays. The fumble that doesn't happen because his knee was just barely down; the acrobatic catch that gets taken away; the buzzer beater that didn't count because it was touching his fingertips for the last tenth of a second. It seems like those kind of replay reversals happen far more often than the opposite scenario (i.e. non-catch switched to a catch) and I find them annoying even if they do benefit my team.