LogFAQs > #876822972

Illuminoius posted...

i wonder how many people prefer sonic 2 just out of nostalgia, which wouldn't surprise me considering how many of them refuse to adequately explain their opinions and just give bullshit like "its level design is consistent in quality and does drag on too long"

Basically, it wins by default because it doesn't have as many bullshit parts as the other games. As even you pointed out, Marble Garden, Carnival Night, and Sandopolis were fucking annoying. S3&K might have had a few of the best levels, but it also had a good chunk of really bad ones; hence S2 having "consistent level design."