57. Lanturn (mnkboy)
I've always kind of liked Lanturn, because Elec and Water are both in my top 5 types, but it gets negative points because of being another damn fish.
56. Bidoof (SuperWhiscash)
Love the Bidoof comics, and I love the derpy faced pokemon. Bidoof is certainly my second favorite "Rattata"
55.Lucario (PrinceKaro)
I really liked Lucario at first, then the damn thing had to be in Brawl and be horribad, which made me like it a lot less. Fighting/Steel is also a werid typing for me since I can kind of see it, but it sort of doesn't make sense.
54. Diglett (Bosco)
Always liked Diglett and though I was never particularly good at Shoddy Battle, Dugtrio has my favorite moment. I just had a crappy stall Dugtrio that had Toxic/Sub/Protect/Dig. Someone's Azelf got me to 25% I used Dig, Triple Troll Face!
53. Cyndaquil (Highwind89)
I was never a huge fan of the second gen starters but they get the job done. Cyndaquil is probably my least favorite of all the fire starters, but it's still probably in my top 60% overall.
52. Vulpix (PrinceKaro)
Vulpix is cute, but it never had much going for it. in RBY if I was using a fire type, it was Growlithe and Vulpix became a less attractive option from there. However, I do love Vulpix because I feel like it marked the decline of Brock as a rock trainer. the sheer randomness of him picking up a fire type is hilarious. It would be like if Misty just said "I will raise this Sandshrew!
51. Braviary (swordz9)
Braviary is pretty cool overall, but I didn't fall in love with it like everyone else on the board. I'm also not patriotic at all, so that's probably why.
50. Glaceon (GTM)
I like all the Eeveelutions except Leafeon, but the gen 4 batch was the weakest IMO. At least it wasn't senselessly retconned into existence like Leafeon, but it was still a pain in the ass to evolve and there was no way I was using it.
49. Sawsbuck (edwardsdv)
I like the season mechanic, but I wish it actually meant something. Like Sawsbuck could have been Ice in Winter, Grass in Spring, Fire in Summer and... uh... Pure Normal in Fall. Also, it kind of confuses me when a random pokemon is Normal/Not-flying. It kind of makes me think a few other things could have been normal type if they were introduced in a different gen. Like Rapidash would have been the perfect Fire/Normal pokemon.
48. Glalie (mnkboy)
I don't get why so many people hate Glalie, I think it's cool. Just a big CHILL guy who's ICE to have around. Not very SLICK in a competitive scenario, but I like the COOL design.
47. Durant (mnkboy)
Damn, did Gen 5 get some awesome new bugs. Durant gets a little overshadowed for not being a new type combo and for not evolving, but as far as future evolutions go, this guy should be top priority.
46. Giratina (htaeD)
Not a whole lot of legendaries made this list, but it's the third highest that did make it, though that's not saying a whole lot. Certainly the best of it's trio, and probably my favorite of the DPP legendaries overall, but not nearly as cool as the first two batches of Legendary trios. I kind of felt as though the Origin Forme was a generally pointless addition, but I don't hate it. It does always annoy me that you can't trade it with the Griscious orb attached, so until B/W you couldn't get the Origin Forme in non Platinum games without promos or cheating.
--
http://i.imgur.com/WRgfu.gif