Yeah Eddie might be able to play more characters and more styles, but just like Shawn's talents might show through better cause he has more opportunities, I think Eddie has the edge there as far as opportunity goes. And I will say I'm more skeptical of Eddie's ability to carry big men like Shawn can than I am Shawn to play a cowardly heel (he's sorta done this as arrogant heel against the right opponents) or a comedy face (I'd argue he's already succeeded at this given how bad his material was with PG-DX and him making it almost work sometimes!)
--
I tried to have a fierce rivalry with SuperNiceDog, but he made me look worse than a GameFAQs Contest!