The Usual Suspects - 8.2
Did a very good job on building up on intrigue and character as the movie went on, and towards the end, I was coming up with theories left and right as to the answer to the million dollar question that the movie poses. I did eventually figure it out before the reveal.
It did everything very well, but nothing tangible, for lack of a better word, was extraordinary, so my high expectations weren't quite met.
--
http://img.imgcake.com/kcftabletpnget.png