LogFAQs > #962333092

Warrior of Light being on the safe list, or being your ACTUAL role as scum (with a mention of you being Elidibus in your role pm) would pop out as a beautifully safe scum claim to my eyes. How were you to know I was going to claim THIS of all things when we were hinting to each other on day 1.

You could very well have expected me to accept you with open arms and have a town buddy confirming you for the rest of the game which I all but already did earlier in the day before I considered this scenario.

Again though, I don't "win no matter what" after today. I still need town to win. Therefore, as Red (or was it plum) pointed out, I'm playing to lose by allowing myself to get lynched when I'm not absolutely 100% certain what your alignment is. If you're indeed town and we mislynch you today, it sucks but we still have you around 100% confirmed and gain a ton of info based on who said what to you over the past two days.

If you get lynched and you flip scum, then woo-hoo we in this boys.

If I get lynched; you're all going to see my flip and not really gain anything because YOU could still be scum and that's basically the end of the game because well have no choice but to treat you as confirmed town for the rest of the game, especially with me whispering things in your ear you may or may not give a damn about.

The only thing everyone can pretty much agree on for today's lynch is I'm obviously not on the mafia team because why in the world would I do this as mafia? So logically, the best chance of success comes through lynching you.

Obviously you disagree because either you KNOW you are town or you're mafia pretending to know that, but most other logical people should be able to follow my train of thought I'd think.