LogFAQs > #939358220

Peeonidas posted...

in my first playthrough it was like, okay that's odd but i've killed predators and not skinned them, and ive accidentally trampled critters. and sure, ive robbed and killed plenty. but i literally made it a point on this, my third playthru, not to be a bad dude. and he still lies for attention like this

I think it's glitched or not well thought out.

I've had a playthrough where Mary Beth's convo happened right after Horseshoe Overlook opened up and Arthur doesn't mention the animals at all, but I typically only kill for hunting and otherwise he always talks about killing animals needlessly.

GTA V had similar problems with Mike and the Therapist but I think it was mostly to do with the game "forgetting" everything you did if you loaded a save and then immediately did the thearpist stuff.

---

Engaging with NPCs is conceptually identical to talking back to the television.