LogFAQs > #905306933

2002: Wasn't on GFAQs yet, but Sonic losing to Samus would have made it bad to me.
2003: Weak performance from Nintendo
2004G: Liked Melee's run, and Halo losing. I wanted OoT to beat FF7 though.
2004C: Boring SSF fest.
2005V: lol get out of the bracket seph contest
2005C: Decent until Sonic lost to MM. We were so close to a Mario vs Sonic final! Also no close matches.
2006S: Meh
2006C: Thank god Samus didn't lose to Tifa; but overall boring.
2007: 4-ways are bad, but this one at at least funny.
2008: Ugh. At least 2007 was amusing.
2009: Better than the previous two contests, but I still don't like 4-ways.
2010C: My overall fav, but 12h matches suck.
2010G: MM doesn't feel like GotD, but neither was Brawl.
2011: Bad idea. Tag teams aren't good.
2013: Draven + lower vote totals + 3-way makes this weak.
2015: Lower vote totals allowed a lame rally to snowball out of control. I'm not against rallies; but it honestly only worked because of bad vote totals.
2017: Boo.