LogFAQs > #977072960

EDumey posted...

Did you respond to my paragraph about Red? What exactly are we "letting him off the hook" from?

I know this is a thing that we struggle with every single mafia game, but wanting to dive off of the people we might actually have information and can make some informed reads on, and onto a player you think is inactive, just isn't appealing at all. Like yeah, we have to have a way of dealing with lower activity players at some point. But I gotta have an argument to vote someone, personally.

red has not engaged with the last two days of game. it's not that he's been inactive, it's that he's been active but has demonstrated absolutely no mental flexibility or willingness to entertain possibilities about my role. you believe i'm scum, but you've discussed it with me. red has just come in and said 'jc's role is scum'.

Like, why bother even asking me to clarify the order of events if the answer isn't going to change your view? Clearly it wasn't, because he asked the question and then stopped caring about the answer. red's mind was not open to being changed, so why was he asking questions?

say that you're alive d4 with red, what has he given you today to work from? he just goes 'oh well i guess i was wrong about jc' and you have absolutely nothing. he is deliberately hiding in the background coasting on my lynch because it's easy.