LogFAQs > #971610550

Kirby321 posted...

I criticized Ben for it because he said he laid down hints. I don't claim to have done such a thing, not earlier than Day 3 at the very least.

Truth be told, I was completely prepared to fake claim Vanilla in a mass claim to conceal my role (which wouldn't have been a complete lie since I was effectively Vanilla until Sultan died), so I made sure not to breadcrumb (though I was fully willing to claim my actual role at the end of Day 2 there when my life was on the line). I know that sounds weird, but I was under the impression that Hero was some sort of powerful role. I wanted my back-up status to be completely hidden from scum until it was necessary for me to claim in full.

Anyway, I'm still in support of a mass claim, so I'm leaving my vote on Red in case he shows up again. Otherwise, I'm still raising my eyebrow at Hb and Ben's roles conflicting in flavor. I'm leaning toward Hb. We've had four Star Spirits claimed, all of whom are vanilla. The only players that claim to be vanilla but not Star Spirits are Hb and Peaf.

I think we get more info out of Hb's lynch. If he flips scum, that lends more credence to Ben's role being legit, and also puts into question whether Peaf is being truthful or not. If Hb flips town, Ben's role is still dubious and Peaf's flavor could still be real.

This post gave me whiplash. Because Kirby has been stating since day 1 how confident he was I was scum, and this is before I role claimed. Before that he was using the "Town Ben has better reads than this" card, and the "trust me I know Ben and he is scum this game" card. Then when I do claim he transitions into that being the sole reason why he thinks I am scum. But now HB is a better lynch because of his flavor claim? And HB being scum town clears me?! Why? Notice he says that if HB flips town then I am still likely scum. This is another reason i think HB is town, because this is a setup to lynch him and then still be able to lynch me the next day