LogFAQs > #971605784

EDumey posted...

If we're trying to talk about information lynches, then I still think Kirby is a very good place to test because it pretty much can soft confirm Ben's alignment as the opposite. And we then get a lot of info based on that. I didn't post much since last night, but I think my preferred action still seems pretty obvious. Lynch Kirby who I think looks the scummiest and just fake claimed, which is also a good information lynch on top of that.

I just can't get over how they very adamantly pushed me to claim (which again, conveniently made it so it wasn't a same-time claim like they initially asked for), then confidently condemned me as scum in their claim post, but then limped away when no one else bought in. I don't know if they were just that confident that their logic on hammer missing was going to make everyone want to lynch me or what.

I am comfortable sitting on this vote and think it's the correct option for lynching scum, AND giving worthwhile info.

I agree with your conclusion but I'm not willing to say that Kirby and Ben are opposites. My argument for why Ben's role would be beneficial to Hero all also applicable to backup Hero.

My stance is that i don't think Kirby is a backup Hero.