LogFAQs > #971604570

T1:
Kirby321 posted...

I... really don't understand what's so cryptic about my post.

I made a dumb joke about the lack of reactions to my opening post.

I offered my thoughts on Plum, then offered my thoughts on the whole Han vs. Sbell thing.

Is giving soft reads on other players not a good thing...? It's obviously too early to say "this person is definitely town/scum"

Sultan, you're at the epicenter of Han and Sbell's whole thing. What do you make of their alignments?

Tldr: cfwr, spin it over to now-confirmed town.

Kirby321 posted...

I don't like that you're avoiding Peaf's question to you. I thought you were getting on Peaf's case because he ignoring you, so this seems awfully hypocritical.

Peaf has a point. You just played a game where Sbell and Han were your scummates. Do you really have nothing to say on their little debate? Why are you tunneling on Peaf based on a very early Day 1 interaction and ignoring the rest of the game?

Latch onto a town argument against another player.

[LFAQs-redacted-quote]

Speaks for herself!

[LFAQs-redacted-quote]

Time will tell if Lea was 1/3 for 2/3, but i still can't get over how fucking hilarious it was that she and sbell killed each other.

Kirby321 posted...

That's diminutive. If there was lots of other stuff going on in the game, then I agree that calling everyone town is the path of least resistance.

But nothing else has happened so far. I'm not going to lie and say "I thought Plum looked scummy for voting right out of the gate" because that's not what I honestly think.

I'm giving you a hard time, in any case. You said you don't have much else of an argument to make and are going on gut. Fair enough; you've debated with me enough to feel that your line of thought is at least cohesive even if it's ultimately wrong.

I don't think my initial impression of your alignment was wrong. This feels like a stark contrast to the last game, where it didn't feel like you were in your town element until Day 2 or 3 (because you were scum).

It feels like Kirby knew that his train would dwindle eventually... because the guy leading it is a teammate.

Kirby321 posted...

Gee, that's a lot of effort just to say you have no reads, amirite?

##Vote: Lea

This is in response to the Lea post i quoted earlier. She said she thought 3 people were town! That's not no reads!

Kirby321 posted separately, trying to get around the quote limit...

Gee, that's a lot of effort just to say you have no reads, amirite?

##Vote: Lea

.

I literally said that I leaned town on Sbell, Plum, and Han in the very post you accused me of stating no reads in.

And here you are stating that they're also town without further elaboration. Yet you claimed I had no reads, even though I shared and stated my reads with reasons to back them up.

This logic doesn't hold up at all. You've contradicted yourself.

He's trying so, so hard to appear town. Got reasons and everything, see!

Still going, but have to do some work. Just fun revisiting old things.