LogFAQs > #971585445

masterplum posted...

I hate mass claims what sort of crazy gas lighting from JC and Han is this.

I wanted an early mass claim last game because I knew it was a cult game and nobody else did

thats fair

Anyways Ill be honest part of the reason I want a mass is because if theres no cop, Ben is possibly somewhat plausible?

If star spirits are in fact the town vanillas, hes a weak cop if he hasnt claimed and suggested to scum that they shouldnt claim star spirits. If someone claims star spirit hes supposed to scan them. His role becomes less productive once hes claimed and scum knows not to claim a star spirit as vanilla.

His role is a weak cop that tests vanilla claims if he hasnt fully claimed.

The role is kind of balanced because until we figure out whether or not star spirits are vanillas, his scan is useless (e.g. if Peaf is scum, and town hasnt figured out star spirits are vanilla, the town does nothing).

It implicitly means Hb and Peaf are scum because they claimed not-star-spirits though.

I am not suggesting this is in fact the case, just spitballing a scenario.