LogFAQs > #968107216

Okay, before I post my thoughts and final flavor, may I say one thing:

Chill the hell out. I fully acknowledge I, as the host, fucked up a few things. I do have a bit of a writeup that I have planned bits and pieces on as the game went on, and I'll post it either here or elsewhere.

The timeskip for what happened with the Red hammer is confusing, but what it boils down to is:
Both Ulti and the Hammerer kill Roshan.
Roshan grants Aegis and Aghanim's Shard to one random killer (Ulti)
Ulti upgrades his role to jailkeeper and attempts to use it on red at night to roleblock; fails, as Red has a Linken's Lotus Sphere.
Time fast forwards 12 hours later, and a tie vote occurs, which Ulti loses, or we utilize the "scum equals or outnumbers town" rule.

OR, BECAUSE THAT IS DUMB
Both Ulti and the Hammerer kill Roshan.
The Hammerer claims the Aegis and an Aghanim's Shard.
See the "scum equals or outnumbers town" rule again, but if not;
Red nightkills Ulti.

In both situations:
Roshan is stuck resurrecting, and cannot win while dead. Game state ends before that time.