LogFAQs > #966803252

Leonhart4 posted...

"I can't explain why Symphonia did so well so there just have been some weird rSFF so I can just ignore that result"

Pointing to the fact that they're both GameCube RPGs with an overlapping fanbase is a logical explanation. ToS defined Cube RPGs more than TTYD did, similar to how Mario defines Nintendo more than Samus does.

Xenoblade getting 60% on TTYD is definitely above its pay grade. That means P4 would too and I don't think even P5 would manage that.

Agreed. I actually edited my previous post a moment ago. No way is TTYD weaker than Three Houses.

I'd say Xenoblade gets 55%+ on TTYD because the Nintendo RPG fanbase sees Xenoblade as a landmark game whereas TTYD was just a great game.

P4 or P5 vs. TTYD is tricky. I could even see TTYD > P4 because I don't think P4 is ready to beat a quality game with the "Mario" label on it. P5, however, probably puts 55%+ on TTYD.