LogFAQs > #965728412

Before reading into any topics just thinking about it a bit.

If Chris is scum, he decided to basically kill some very strong scum roles, which is a huge pay to try to paint himself as the obvious town. His roles are also not something we've seen in action so either that's gone completely undetected or the scum team for some reason has it's 2/12 non-power roles on the same person, which seems unlikely. He also doesn't get Isquen to backup poison. Poison having gone off would likely have meant we would have lost the game at this point, which I find quite unlikely. Fellow scum member Ben then also decides to use his ability on a fellow scum member, which would then have to be part of the strategy. Otherwise he didn't use it, which I don't believe. I'm having a hard time seeing this being the play.

When I reread day 1 earlier I noticed that one of the first things Ben said was that he was sad he and Chris weren't scum together because he thought of a perhaps fake claim for them. This is one of the many interactions that I have a hard time seeing them puzzle together. I know very little about how they usually play, but man, that would be impressive. I also noticed Chris using Luke Skywalker as an example for flavor character lol.

Corrik was after Chris for two days striaght then gets night killed. That the reason? Good bet if Chris is indeed scum, it seems a bit random at this point right now unless I'm forgetting something from day 2. Chris is also the main reason behind chang's lynch on day 3, which if scum, would have given them another day as the next day Arti was getting lynched just like he seemed to be on day 3 if not for the push on chang.

Much later we see a bulletproof role flip. This role straight up has no function if Chris is not town which seems quite unlikely though not technically impossible of course. I'm finding it more likely that MZero's role had specifications that weren't relevant just to make sure there would be no questions and not hinting anything. The roles have been very specific in general.

I have a hard time thinking this is the more likely lynch candidate, but that doesn't mean I'm giving up on the thought (seems I have to stress that).