LogFAQs > #961823705

I have my doubts. HSreplay doesn't list rogue until the 10th deck in terms of winrate. Thief rogue is second-played with a whopping 6% of the meta. Quest warrior is twice as prevalent, is the top of tier 1, and is the deck I find myself consistently losing to on the occasions I try to complete a few quests.

It's also not a bad deck that's horribly meta-warping, or there'd be way more discussion about it elsewhere. I remember the days of (the original) quest rogue. Caverns Below was the single worst deck this game has ever had, to the extent that Blizzard nerfed the quest twice and it still saw play as an obnoxious and perverting deck an expansion later. I could name other decks that were very bad, unhealthy, or toxic, but just Quest Rogue alone is a high enough bar that I couldn't possibly imagine anything worse without it blowing up everywhere -- even for me, who isn't actively running in those circles any more.

If there is a rogue deck that really is that bad, please link me to a CC talking about it so I can understand better.