My biggest complaint with it is simply how many characters they put up as DLC. Twelve of them? Really? That's a full 20% of the game's roster, on the disc, that you can't play as. Six characters might have been fine. But you can't argue that it's "a complete game" when there's that many characters missing.
For example, Soul Calibur V has an on-disc DLC character, Dampierre. But he's just one gimmicky character with no place in the plot. The game doesn't feel any less complete for not having him. I'm not even defending SCV's DLC policies here, the way they dealt with Dampierre was honestly pretty dumb, but at least it wasn't literally sealing away a full fifth of the game's content.
--
xfd dude, it's just a popularity contest on the internets.
-Vlado