When have I ever let you down before when we've both been town!
Outside the obvious, I think silver is obvtown. I thought the same D1 of Chaos mafia, and he's exactly the same here.
I'm not sure about Drak. If there's one thing I've earmarked about his scumplay in the past, it's that he likes to pick on easy lynches. Other than that it can be hard to distinguish because he plays scum quite well. When he's town, he's always among the most insightful in the game, but he's never blase about it, which he can then pull off as scum. Whilst I think his vote on XIII is a little lazy, it's too soon to call him scum for it.
I kind of feel like I should look into plum's name drops more. He has a real habit of going half-and-half with who he decides to talk about, regardless of whether he's speaking favourably about them or not. I'd be very surprised if he didn't say at least one scumbuddy was townish or scummy. I know people have brought up jdizzy and Dante, but I'll probably see if he mentioned anyone else.
--
"Eet's game time..."