Board 8 > Toy Story Mafia Topic 3 - Batteries & Battery

(+) Yeah! (+)

Ctes, my change of heart on FD, is that a problem for you? Since you brought it up

I just think for looking at trends they can be better.

I'm curious to Ben leaving out Death of the 3 actually and forgetting Lopen's suspicion of him. Lopen actually never had me in the names or backup names of a Corrik kill, which struck me as interesting at the time, but did have Death.

Isnt it also like 9 PM over there?

Ben respond to clothing issues immediately.

please and thank you good sir.

Ben respond to clothing issues immediately.

please and thank you good sir.

over where?

I worded that badly.
I did think it was possible that Lopen was bluffing.
Just sounded like a Lopen move he could make to save himself, day2 consequences be damned.

Ben respond to clothing issues immediately.

please and thank you good sir.

Yeah I didn't get any gifts at night. I was bluffing to see how Knightz would react and if he played along and I still thought he was town then I could use it for future bluffs or to keep protecting him from getting lynched. If there was any chance he was scum I thought this could potentially catch him in some way too

But why Benjamin. Would you walk into Day 2 and thank Knightz for a gift when you don't know who he gifted to? Why would you create a possible counter situation in the day. Why did you need to challenge Knightz who most people already thought was town including yourself.

Why would you be thinking about this unless you were on a team considering killing him at night and worrying that he's just bluffing?

Oh I did not think he would claim tracker as scum because there was (almost certainly) another killer out there that might kill him for it.
Also it certainly was not unprovoked. Lopen was leading in votes!

You didn't know he targeted Kirby.

You didn't know he was roleblocked.

You didn't know if someone alive had actually been gifted clothes.

Why did you openly claiming to have a gift unless you know damn well that no one does.

The first half of this question pinged me as slightly off for Ben, I think. Its actually not a strange question to ask in general and especially not the second question, but I wouldnt expect Ben to ask me what is the point of sending a message at all?. If he just asked whether my role was compulsive I wouldnt have thought anything of it.

but i would expect Ben in particular to know that compulsive or not, I would send a message for fun (simply because I can) regardless of whether it were optimal or not. In this case though it is optimal, because its a confirmable power that (from my perspective) most people will consider to be town, conspiracy theories not withstanding.

I am not compulsive though, so if youre worried Im some kind of scary role nerfed by being required to write messages to everyone, thats not the case. you can pick any night you please and I wont send a message just to confirm that aspect.

I can send exactly one post per night at any time, posted by the host (at his availability) and I can include images and stuff too. theres no special rules for the post as long as it fits in a single post and follows the game rules from T1P1.

You didn't know he targeted Kirby.

You didn't know he was roleblocked.

You didn't know if someone alive had actually been gifted clothes.

Why did you openly claiming to have a gift unless you know damn well that no one does.

This. All of this.

And if I was scum then I presumably WOULD know some of this, like that Knightz was roleblocked. >_>

hmm. I said why are you all voting Lopen. I voted for Mzero and Not lopen. I told Lopen not to claim and to stop this garbage.

The Claw can only do so much.

I can buy the roleblock thinking on it. Kirby being power was a lucky shot and Lopen was probably an EK, so if Knightz is town and if there is a scum blocker then why not take the layup and block the guy who claimed he could give people gifts.

but I don't know how Ben's interaction fits into this at all.

Minor curiosity probably, but what do you mean by 'this garbage'?

Not unless you were on the other nontown team.
Also did you have more town motivations than the one you sorta gave?
Why talk about them as if they are disconnected from you?

the bartering for kills with corrik and the piling of votes on lopen.

Could potentially figure out if scum got the real gift depending on if they killed me at night or not (If they believed me). Or I could bluff that the gift was anything if needed to get more info.

Did Ben bluff before he as town could have known about roleblocks and such?

I picked Kirby because he asked for some clothing.