Current Events > Woah wtf. How heavy are black holes??? One punch man spoilers

(+) Yeah! (+)

https://gamefaqs.gamespot.com/a/user_image/8/6/3/AAZsuhAAE3AH.jpg

Well mini black holes. Is this realistic?

This is like a how wet is water question

What is punch man even doing at this point? Didn't he beat Garo?

ViewtifulJoe posted...

What is punch man even doing at this point? Didn't he beat Garo?

Someday he'll get that mosquito

Ratchetrockon posted...

Well mini black holes. Is this realistic?

Hawking strongly suggested that a black hole the size of a beachball would evaporate within a second or two, possible much sooner.

In college, I used to bench 3 black holes easy. I probably should've gone pro

[LFAQs-redacted-quote]


I can lift the bar hehe

ViewtifulJoe posted...

What is punch man even doing at this point? Didn't he beat Garo?

Idk i don't even read the manga anymore. I just check out the raws (which I can't read) whenever they release and look for cool feats lol

Ratchetrockon posted...

I can lift the bar

The bar is supporting two black holes. You probably couldn't lift that either.

Ratchetrockon posted...

Well mini black holes. Is this realistic?

He's the thing. Black holes "weigh" exactly as much as the star that made them. The only thing that changes is the density. I don't know how light you have to be to get an event horizon that small but it seems like the bar might actually weigh more than the black holes.

I'm less impressed by the dude and more impressed by whoever built that bench.

Questionmarktarius posted...

Hawking strongly suggested that a black hole the size of a beachball would evaporate within a second or two, possible much sooner.

Yeah but he was too lazy to walk so

ViewtifulJoe posted...

What is punch man even doing at this point? Didn't he beat Garo?

He did. The giant Monster Association/Garou saga is over, now they are setting up a few different arcs. We just got a pretty sweet Saitama vs. Tatsumaki fight. The big upcoming saga being setup is the Neo Heroes, basically a new hero organization that was set up because the Hero Organization is corrupt. If it follows the webcomic, we should be getting a bunch of mini arcs coming up, similar to how One Punch Man was before the Monster Association attack.

Ppl on opm subreddit say this like benching 40 earths (20 earths per miniblack hole)

Wtf is this true

Ratchetrockon posted...

Is this realistic?

Absolutely. OnePunch Man is famous for the author's rigorous dedication to scientific accuracy.

Ratchetrockon posted...

Ppl on opm subreddit say this like benching 40 earths (20 earths per miniblack hole)

Wtf is this true

I ran some napkin math on Schwarzschild radius if we assume those are Schwartzschild black holes and it's about 33.82 earths per black hole.

Tyranthraxus posted...

I ran some napkin math on Schwarzschild radius if we assume those are Schwartzschild black holes and it's about 33.82 earths per black hole.

Awesome

Those would be really heavy still. A basketball sized black hole would weigh close to 13.5 earths apparently.

Also Bender was able to move a piece of dark matter which was stated to weigh as much as a thousand suns

Irony posted...

Also Bender was able to move a piece of dark matter which was stated to weigh as much as a thousand suns

he is powerful

Ratchetrockon posted...

Ppl on opm subreddit say this like benching 40 earths (20 earths per miniblack hole)

Wtf is this true

i think it's closer to 41

Goku = dead

he has to have some sort of graviton control force

even the tiniest black hole would instantly expand and consume everything. the fact that the large hadron collider was allowed to be turned on with even a .0000001% chance of creating a black hole is insane. that's the sort of thing that should be fixed beforehand. no one is approving a nuclear power plant with a .000001% chance of instantly melting down when you turn it on, nevermind creating a black hole

thronedfire2 posted...

even the tiniest black hole would instantly expand and consume everything

Not everything

Not Saitama

Goku maybe

thronedfire2 posted...

he has to have some sort of graviton control force

even the tiniest black hole would instantly expand and consume everything. the fact that the large hadron collider was allowed to be turned on with even a .0000001% chance of creating a black hole is insane. that's the sort of thing that should be fixed beforehand. no one is approving a nuclear power plant with a .000001% chance of instantly melting down when you turn it on, nevermind creating a black hole

Its just a cover page, its not actually part of the story

AngelsNAirwav3s posted...

Its just a cover page, its not actually part of the story

Mad Goku stan?

Is this still a parody?

im 99% sure we are not suppose to take chapter images like this as canon

Irony posted...

Also Bender was able to move a piece of dark matter which was stated to weigh as much as a thousand suns

Bender > one punch man confirmed

AceMos posted...

im 99% sure we are not suppose to take chapter images like this as canon

i think it ok for composite saitama

if regular saitama then not ok

but anyways cover photos showed saitama punching a hole through a moon years before he actually did destroy a moon. so i think it likely Murata envisions saitama to be this powerful and i expect to see this type of feat to occur in main story someday :)

WingsOfGood posted...

Goku = dead

yeah i think goku is washed these days. he had one universal feat from almost a decade ago and nothing even comes close to it since then. i honestly think beerus is 99% the reason why that even happened and goku can't replicate that against opponents that are around his level.

idk where to even put him these days cuz of all the low showings in super. hard to see him as a universal or galaxy threat. he got hurt by bullet, almost died to a laser pistol (saved because of senzu bean iirc), his evil counterpart shocked by a sniper rifle. what else is there?

most of his battles only destroy mountain ranges at most.

also in character Goku will allow Saitama to get stronger than him during their fight anyways (cuz saitama grows exponentially like Broly but he can also copy advance techniques like time travel in a few seconds). so even if goku is a universal threat he'd still lose cuz he doesn't start out that way. broly certainly wasn't universal in his earliest form lol.

Are you asking for actual science in a parody series

Ratchetrockon posted...

also in character Goku will allow Saitama to get stronger than him during their fight anyways (cuz saitama grows exponentially like Broly but he can also copy advance techniques like time travel in a few seconds). so even if goku is a universal threat he'd still lose cuz he doesn't start out that way. broly certainly wasn't universal in his earliest form lol.

Saitama don't need to grow

he is lifting two black holes like they nothing

WingsOfGood posted...

Saitama don't need to grow

he is lifting two black holes like they nothing

Ok you're right.

Tyranthraxus posted...

Black holes "weigh" exactly as much as the star that made them. The only thing that changes is the density.

I've often thought about this, but since stars lose much of their mass by exploding it out into space during their supernova, wouldn't the ensuing black hole have less mass?

If the star was big enough to blow up and make a black hole out of the bits left behind, the ejected matter will come back eventually.