Board 8 > Simpsons Mafia Topic 7 Krusty Burger is now closed

(+) Yeah! (+)

htaeD posted...

I dont know why he'd defend Han to this extent given Hans questionable at times behavior.

Post 325. It is just something i can't see sum han doing.

---

Crescent-Moon posted...

My issue is he was not hard defending Han like this before.

We also had a good talk where we were both attempting to solve the game last night in the neighbour chat, so that really helped cement my thoughts about him.

---

IfGodCouldDie posted...

Me and Han were getting in to it day 2 I want to say. Instead of goading me into my usual stubborn erratic self that I normally fall into he calmly talked to me helping me to see where I was misunderstanding. If Han was scum, I dont see him doing that. I am notoriously easy to mislynch because of how I usually play, I have since made a resolution to try and be a better more cooperative player(han even said that he doesnt want me to change how I play because my stubborn erratic behavior is normally how he reads me town.)

Okay thats fair, but he might have feared you would talk to us about it and we'd tell you that Han was just goading you if he did try it.
---

Suprak looked really good when he was around, and that should transfer over to Tange. You're also suggesting both neighbors are scum which seems fairly unlikely.
---

Hb to be frank I don't care about your opinion and you would be my choice for Lea to hide behind.

---

And yes I may be wrong on IGCD. It could be Han/Tange/You/Sbell

---

Crescent-Moon posted...

Hb to be frank I don't care about your opinion and you would be my choice for Lea to hide behind.

Well too fucking bad.
---

Yeah we're not doing anything until he shows up I say. And if he isnt getting replaced for not posting a whole day (which is against the rules mind you), then whatever anyway.

But really
If its 4 scum, it cant be you, it cant be me (though I know thats only valid data to me), and at least one HB/Mzero has to be real IMO.

that does give us at least good odds at hitting scum.

Tange also needs to claim, doesnt he?
I dont think I am getting that sametime any time soon.
---

Hbthebattle posted...

Suprak looked really good when he was around, and that should transfer over to Tange. You're also suggesting both neighbors are scum which seems fairly unlikely.

Unlikely, but not impossible.
Especially if one of them is a godfather, it is a safer than not play to make.
I want to say I trust IGCD at least, but Crescent does have a point (mechanically).
---

Reds miller claim points to HB being legit. (moreso than Lol Lea's role)
---

That is if we believe Red even. I kept remembering it as a joke claim.
---

Leanansidhe posted...

I mean

Scum can just, you know, fake claim neighbours together. It's not like it's a real power

What I said.
Oh and right KBM
I keep forgetting about her
---

Leanansidhe posted...

Y'all really believe a flavour less Miller claim?

Like I said, I remebered it as a joke, but also thought that it was genuine because people brought it up again.
I didnt look back.
---

That would expose the other immediately upon flip if we decided to lynch one of them.
---

The problem I've had with Hb is he only picks the arguments he wants to and ignores everything else. He's played very safe under the claim of a role he should expect to die at a moment's notice.

---

I can't be naive. There's something that happened to me that proves that I can get guilty scans.

I can not elaborate, do not ask me to.
---

Its too late to change the time, Lea. Sadly. Hbthebattle posted...

That would expose the other immediately upon flip if we decided to lynch one of them.

Neighbors arent always town/town unlike Masons
---

htaeD posted...

Its too late to change the time, Lea. Sadly.
Neighbors arent always town/town unlike Masons

I am aware. But if they were faking the neighbor claims altogether, their role wouldn't be "neighbor", exposing the other as lying immediately.
---

Well thats all we need to know HB. Since the problem is about whether you are scum or not first regardless.
---

Hbthebattle posted...

I can't be naive. There's something that happened to me that proves that I can get guilty scans.

I can not elaborate, do not ask me to.

Um

---

Hbthebattle posted...

I am aware. But if they were faking the neighbor claims altogether, their role wouldn't be "neighbor", exposing the other as lying immediately.

Oh right. Its still not impossible that both are scum. But less likely.
---

@VengefulKaelee

Wanna claim with me?
---

SBell went dead quiet on yet another crucial claim, just like he did with MZero.

Something incredibly obvious just occurred to me.

Won't Han flip SCUM Neighbor when he dies?

My hesitation towards SBell's scan (reminder he ASKED to be scanned) was misplaced.

Han/Tange/SBell/One of Hb/MZero


---

Crescent/Lea/Death/Kaelee/IGCD towncore (assuming Han flips scum neighbor)

Han/Tange/SBell scumcore

1 remaining power that is lying. Lea can figure out who.

If this is all correct...

---

Leanansidhe posted...

Sbell asked not to be scanned, then he asked to be scanned, then he got mad he got scanned

SBell baited it. Regardless of if it's his teammate or not.

---

We have way too much town clearing power it feels like.

---

I can't deny that there's a possibility I'm insane, though. My role pm called me incompetent and says to point my finger and hope I'm right, though.

I hope not, though, 'cause insane cop's a stupid role.
---

Didnt you just say...the opposite?
---

Well if SBell flips scum not godfather... Things get complex.

Heavily considering lynching SBell first. Not sure.

---

htaeD posted...

Didnt you just say...the opposite?

...More or less?

---

Of course, we could just have you scan Crescent to find out.
---

htaeD posted...

Didnt you just say...the opposite?

I said I'm not Naive. Naive Cop always gets Town as a result.
Insane Cop gets the opposite of the true result.
---

If we're lynching one of my scans, I'd prefer Kaelee to be first, as its somewhat connected to the "I know I'm not naive" thing.

I'm trying to explain this in a way that doesn't get me modkilled.
---

Oh ok.

Anyway I want to say
based on votals alone I'd say for Lea to be town, IGCD or Sbell has to be scum (or scum has only 3 members left)
But then again for all I know scum missed a scumhammer moment due to Mzero.
---

Hbthebattle posted...

If we're lynching one of my scans, I'd prefer Kaelee to be first, as its somewhat connected to the "I know I'm not naive" thing.

I'm trying to explain this in a way that doesn't get me modkilled.

Just ask the host what you can and cant say.
---

Leanansidhe posted...

We all get it

And by get it, I mean get Simpsons references

I dont. But I think I missed something.
---

Under no circumstances are we lynching Kaelee before SBell.

---

htaeD posted...

Oh ok.

Anyway I want to say
based on votals alone I'd say for Lea to be town, IGCD or Sbell has to be scum (or scum has only 3 members left)
But then again for all I know scum missed a scumhammer moment due to Mzero.

Kaelee was on for only a minute or two. I asked her to get off.

---