Board 8 > A Dance With Dragons Mafia:Topic 9-I tried to grasp a star,overreached, and fell

(+) Yeah! (+)

reportquote
benjamin3740 9/28/2018 6:05:19 PM#398
IfGodCouldDie posted...
People to look at when I flip.

MI, Sheep and Chris. Each one of these players has called me town for the exact same plays in previous games but have decided that this is the game to call me scum over it.

It's kind of hard to see where you're coming from though when the example is so vague. Do you really think they called you Town for being contradictory or making mistakes in general? What should we be seeing in you this game that proves you town?


Yeah IGCD looking good
---

dowolf 9/28/2018 6:37:46 PM#458
IfGodCouldDie posted...
dowolf posted...
Also, has Sheep even played that many games with God?

We played a lot when people called me corrik-lite.

That was a thing?

Also, I'm sorry.
benjamin3740 posted...
DoomTheGyarados posted...
benjamin3740 posted...
show hidden quote(s)

Maybe you are scum.

If only ;-;

???


town points for Dewolf YEAH IM BRINGIN ITBACK
---

benjamin3740 9/28/2018 7:09:57 PM#48
Plum is really under the radar

town point for plum
---

red13n 9/28/2018 6:50:19 PM#30
DoomTheGyarados posted...
Red I don't give a fuck. Seriously. I am one of the best town defenders on the planet. Make a good case. I am eating wasabi peas trying to clear my sinus at lunch. Call it weak if you like igcd will be lynched over my dead body.

This is honestly a really bad look. Your argument has basically been "hes town because chris says hes town".

Regardless of alignment of IGCD, from you it looks weak.


town points igcd
---

benjamin3740 9/28/2018 11:17:46 PM#179
TotallyNotMI posted...
I like you ben!

Although you backing off IGCD did slightly make me wonder if he is a power role and you were looking for a reason to get off your teammate but that thought didn't last long.

I don't feel like I've ever been completely ON IGCD. Mainly afraid that he's just town making mistakes. I got him to contradict himself, but then I recall him doing that before as town. I think he just says whatever he feels is the best response to a post without thinking of staying consistent. Just lynched him as town two games ago because he did that.

Now what I dont like is him saying that a bunch of us should be aware that he is town when he does that.... no that is not an acceptable defense. Yes maybe you do it as town, but no one has ever called you town BECAUSE you contradicted yourself.

yeah igcd looks good to me
---

and then the whole red shitting on tange thing
---

is no one else around?
---

red13n 9/29/2018 2:20:04 PM#146
DoomTheGyarados posted...
Plum sucking up hard is the best plum.

Anyway you guys have me for 15 minutes before work. I won't be home for a long time so ask now!

anyway chris, what is wrong with plum, and you know it, is that I know you. You know damn well that when I say to lynch you, you should be lynched. And you know damn well every poke and prod at you is to get more crap out of you to get a better read.

plum is basically saying it doesn't matter, discounting the possibility, and being full sheep. If I thought you were 100% scum(Which, if you are scum, I'll hit at some point in all likelihood, theres no Corrik here to throw me off my game), and saying to lynch you, and he started to try to derail that, I'd be absolutely 100% pissed as fuck.

But the guy is literally pre-emptively doing it.

town points for plum
---

benjamin3740 9/29/2018 1:49:31 PM#117
Blade suddenly started interacting with people other than Chris after my post suspecting him for it, and the scum vibes have since then turned into town vibes. Maybe he's playing me hard, but its a good sign that he's engaged with the game.

Scare does not seem as engaged as he has been in past town games and it stands out to me


Semi shade on blade and me, town points to blade
---

d13n 9/29/2018 2:23:28 PM#151
Hell I'm starting to lean 2 possibilities.

Chris is town, scum plum is sucking up for brownie points.,
Chris is scum, scum plum is putting up an easy to brush off defense later("it was chris why lynch him").

Its a statement I expect from a lost puppy like shad, not a player that is usually somewhat on point like plum.

this is that post I didnt like. He calls plum scum in both scenarios, but he doesnt vote.

Im thinking now that this was just to plant his seeds to vote chris later and keep plum open as an option too. So I am going back to this just meaning Plum is town
---

benjamin3740 9/29/2018 6:38:33 PM#366
I want to b8 special Mzero. Only reason I havent voted is because...does his timezone even allow him to be around any time before deadline?


town points mzero
---

Leafeon13N posted...

Obellisk posted...

Leafeon13N posted...

Obellisk posted...

red13n posted...

Also apologies my little cousins lost their dog and i'm going out to help look for him. Won't be quite as around as I want to be.

and you are happy leaving on tange?

I'd be pretty happy to leave tange lynched, yeah.

Right now nothing as glaring as last game from sheep.

Need chris to show up and show some fire.

so with a 7 / 7 split between sheep and chris, if you were to make a deciding vote youd go on?

We have two hours and change for information to come in on that account right now.

Red being non commital, town points sbell for trying to get info out of red
---

benjamin3740 posted...

Shad feels like he started very active and fell off.

benjamin3740 posted...

Shad feels like he started very active and fell off.

points for shad
---

benjamin3740 posted...

Too late in the day for me to start thinking about Shad though

that was supposed to be second quote
---

really we have 5 but not eod

ugh
---

well end of day was just like half the page
---

well the only one I didnt feel had any town points was death

so I think I am starting there

##Vote: Death
---

reportquote
HanOfTheNekos 10/1/2018 7:24:42 AM#198
MZero11 posted...
ScareChan posted...
wait mi is dead and posting through ghost

is he in the dvc? can he talk to chris still? if so we can see who chris JK'd last night

Obviously none of us would know this >_>

But you can wait and see if he tells us.

Kinda disheartened, with both MI and Chris flipping Town and both Red and Ben flipping Scum. That means my reads are backwards.

... which means Shad is Scum.

I don't actually believe that.

Here's an important point for y'all: Viserion was on Sheep at the day's end. If we are to believe that Viserion is a Scum-controlled doublevote (Targaryen basically confirms that), then Sheep is likely not Scum. Unless the gambit was "use doublevote to force a tie between our player and Chris, then break the tie before anyone else", Sheep should NOT be Scum.

##Vote: Death

I wasn't doing too hot yesterday, but I also was not very engaged due to having the two busiest days of the week for me. I'd like to reread day 1 if I have the time, but my time is still limited, so you'll be getting a lot out of me tonight, and I should have some time tomorrow.

Chris pinged on Death early yesterday. No reason not to follow the wise words.

We've already got two Scum down (shame about it being a MK but whatever). No reason to let up now. This Town's gotta be...


Han first post day 2 is responding to questions about DVC and voting death saying Chris pinged him

Yeah I definitely like my death vote
---

okay a bit tired out now, going to chill for a bit, but if somoene comes in down to chat
---

Death is a fine route today

I would really like to force a dowolf claim though
---

I couldnt agree more

Hey dowolf, claim

##Vote: dowolf
---

Also using dead Han, who probably was reading Chris' dead chats to support his attack on me, is double lazy
---

I used dead scum to see that they didnt leave any town points for you, and dead han likely listening to dead Chris to back up that very live feeling I have
---

doesnt mean their feeling is right
---

Also your point system feels rather arbitrary
I admit that I dont remember Red or Ben talking about me tho
---

Well the point system isn't perfect. no. You can't be the ONLY scum left. But i feel this is a good direction
---

Well you will forgive me for not bothering with something that cant be responded too.
---

I woke up excited to see what fireworks occured and instead we have basically nothing

##vote:Dowolf

Lets see the claim.
---

what fireworks were you expecting?
---

Mzero/Dowolf having claimed by now
---

MZero11 posted...

Obellisk posted...

why do you think hes town.

and you cant know your poisoned. that's absurd

I touched on it yesterday, but Scum Scare barely posts and when he does it's like objectively wrong to anyone paying attention. Also he went pretty hard on Pirate yesterday but he was also open to me and Sheep whereas Scum Scare I think just parks it on Pirate and calls it a day. He also was rereading topics which I don't see from Scum Scare

I've never been wrong on a Scare read some I'm pretty confident tbh

except literally everyone said we are not lynching pirate. so scare had to move around. pirate was never going to flip scum.
---

DoubleTangicide posted...

Ive played both ways....where you find out youre poisoned and when you dont

pirate never told us he was poisoned. or he was notified of anything. so nope.
---

IfGodCouldDie posted...

Obellisk posted...

IfGodCouldDie posted...

Obellisk posted...

IfGodCouldDie posted...

Shaduln posted...

For the record, I don't think I actually called your response cute, Scare. I just said that typically I find cute responses are scum.

Not gonna do a ton tonight because of a cranky baby/playing armello w/ friends. Unfortunate result, but I stand by that lynch any game.

Armello on?

came back for a non mafia related post did ya?

Been here the whole time, actually.

not posting = not playing = not here

I wholeheartedly disagree. I'd appreciate if you'd stop reaching for reasons to make me look bad.

you do it all on your own. you don't need my help
---

looking back again

i should probably figure out who i want people to go after tomorrow...

Dowolf saying he wants to let us do the work for hi, huh. Why cant he do that himself?

Also him saying scare was being saved, when probably meant sheep.
A slip perhaps? (That Scare was the one being saved after all)

Not particularly a fan of Plum and IGCD both pulling the breaks on the scare special regardless.
But that depends on what Scare is. And I dont like playing like we need to move from info lynch to info lynch
---

masterplum posted...

MZero11 posted...

##Vote: dowolf

Gonna need a claim from you buddy

Not a fan of this. Didnt need to out yourself yet, especially considering Dowolf was on the short list of suspects by both Han and blade after scare.

If dowolf is scum, Plum probably is as well with the way he immediately assumes a guilty scan here.
---

Obellisk posted...

ScareChan posted...

There was only 1 death today, today was the day poison should have happened, just putting a theory out there

scum team saved their kill for end game last game.

Its also possible scums poison got intercepted by Chris
---

Morning,

I give it to Scare he pinged my towny senses when he did so much isoing when nobody was around to interact with. I've seen scum do it as well, but generally i give town points for trying to put thoughts into the thread even if its somewhat wifom scum filter eh.

But i am here now.

I was scum once down to the final four. everyone wanted my head. I spent days (no deadline for final day) iso'ing and arguing posts the remaining people made.

I won that game for scum.

so scare gets no town points sitting there defending himself and igcd.
---

ScareChan posted...

benjamin3740 9/29/2018 6:38:33 PM#366
I want to b8 special Mzero. Only reason I havent voted is because...does his timezone even allow him to be around any time before deadline?


town points mzero

"I want to vote him, but I don't think I ethically can" -- sounds like a bus to me tbqh.

Anyways, look. I scan innocent. I did not target Han last night. I have no idea what "info" Mzero's pretending to have, but it's false.
---

anyways gonna go ahead and ##Vote: MZero

hints info, disappears for a half-hour, claims info, disappears again, and says he's open to lynching people who aren't me. While claiming to have info on me.

Nothing about that passes the smell test.
---

dowolf posted...

anyways gonna go ahead and ##Vote: MZero

hints info, disappears for a half-hour, claims info, disappears again, and says he's open to lynching people who aren't me. While claiming to have info on me.

Nothing about that passes the smell test.

hey didnt scare do that to a obv town pirate earlier?
---

Obellisk posted...

dowolf posted...

anyways gonna go ahead and ##Vote: MZero

hints info, disappears for a half-hour, claims info, disappears again, and says he's open to lynching people who aren't me. While claiming to have info on me.

Nothing about that passes the smell test.

hey didnt scare do that to a obv town pirate earlier?

...Scare didn't sit on Pirate for nine hours and threaten to do so for 48, did he?

I remember that happened over the course of me catching up after work, so I have no instinctual sense for how long that took.
---

Obellisk posted...

dowolf posted...

anyways gonna go ahead and ##Vote: MZero

hints info, disappears for a half-hour, claims info, disappears again, and says he's open to lynching people who aren't me. While claiming to have info on me.

Nothing about that passes the smell test.

hey didnt scare do that to a obv town pirate earlier?

Kind of. I liked when scare did it because pirate was a great target to crack.

Dowolf is not a good target.

I have thoughts about this so far but I think its prudent to not say anything yet
---

dowolf posted...

Obellisk posted...

dowolf posted...

anyways gonna go ahead and ##Vote: MZero

hints info, disappears for a half-hour, claims info, disappears again, and says he's open to lynching people who aren't me. While claiming to have info on me.

Nothing about that passes the smell test.

hey didnt scare do that to a obv town pirate earlier?

...Scare didn't sit on Pirate for nine hours and threaten to do so for 48, did he?

I remember that happened over the course of me catching up after work, so I have no instinctual sense for how long that took.

Scare waited pretty long to take back his bluff tho.
but he didnt make himself sound as believable either, while giving info at the same time.

But I will be honest and say I didnt even notice Mzero was hinting info when I made my vote.
---

htaeD posted...

masterplum posted...

MZero11 posted...

##Vote: dowolf

Gonna need a claim from you buddy

Not a fan of this. Didnt need to out yourself yet, especially considering Dowolf was on the short list of suspects by both Han and blade after scare.

If dowolf is scum, Plum probably is as well with the way he immediately assumes a guilty scan here.

Wait,

You didnt assume a guilty scan here?
---

masterplum posted...

htaeD posted...

masterplum posted...

MZero11 posted...

##Vote: dowolf

Gonna need a claim from you buddy

Not a fan of this. Didnt need to out yourself yet, especially considering Dowolf was on the short list of suspects by both Han and blade after scare.

If dowolf is scum, Plum probably is as well with the way he immediately assumes a guilty scan here.

Wait,

You didnt assume a guilty scan here?

!!!
---

scare's double duty was what threw my senses off.

Btw, when Mzero gets back here, and if he is in fact serious, I want to know why he didnt wait a while with his info.
---

Dont get excited.

What I meant to say was that I didnt even notice Mzero was giving a hint at a scan at all.
I thought mzero was just voting dowolf because he looked bad.
---

Im #Turnabouting this

If Mzero doesnt have a guilty scan I think Death might have slipped
---

htaeD posted...

Btw, when Mzero gets back here, and if he is in fact serious, I want to know why he didnt wait a while with his info.

how many times do I have to tell you this -- he doesn't have info!
---