Board 8 > TV Crossover Mafia - Topic 6 - Halitosis--first sign of evil.

(+) Yeah! (+)

Corrik posted...

Pirate_Harris posted...

If I was actually town doc... would it had been dumb to role claim day 1?

Usually as town doctor you fakeclaim vanilla if you are forced to claim unless you will die otherwise besides claiming doctor.

You did good when I counterclaimed you though.

That's good.... my town game is different to my scum game as you sort of have a glimpse of my scum game being to be inactive as to not draw attention
---

You know it's actually not A bad scum team me, plum, ed, ???... they were super helpful
---

Pirate_Harris posted...

Bye guys... *burp* eat shit losers

Last one
---

Votals (through post #153)
[4] Pirate - (Corrik), PJ, FD, Corrik, SBell
[1] Corrik - Pirate
[0] PJ - (FD)
[0] Tange - (Pirate)
[0] SBell - (Pirate)

It is now day 4. With 9 alive, it takes 5 to lynch. Day ends on September 16th at 10:00 PM.
---

##unvote
##vote: FD
---

FD, you're the only person still playing I feel I can trust with a good clean theory.

thought on the possibilities that corrik and pirate are in fact teammates here?

talk in the morning, bed now.
---

Obellisk posted...

FD, you're the only person still playing I feel I can trust with a good clean theory.

thought on the possibilities that corrik and pirate are in fact teammates here?

talk in the morning, bed now.

What if fd is in cahoots with me? What if he's the fourth man?
---

Obellisk posted...

FD, you're the only person still playing I feel I can trust with a good clean theory.

thought on the possibilities that corrik and pirate are in fact teammates here?

talk in the morning, bed now.

Lol at thinking my team would be in this scenario with me.
---

Corrik posted...

Obellisk posted...

FD, you're the only person still playing I feel I can trust with a good clean theory.

thought on the possibilities that corrik and pirate are in fact teammates here?

talk in the morning, bed now.

Lol at thinking my team would be in this scenario with me.

We were team mates... you would bus the shit out of me
---

It kind of is why Sbell not being the last scum is hard to get to over Sultan. He keeps trying to gauge interest in my mislynch all game. Literally with the argument, hey "what is the chances that Corrik just offered up every single teammate to be the last scum left with 3 mislynches needed to win while confirming half the game town"

Hmmm.
---

Well you keep trying to out the mason so there's that.

And there isn't much stopping you from walking back your confirmed town reads if the need arose.

I'm not going to say it's likely, but I'm not prepared to rule it out either.
---

Mason not claiming is literally the worst play this entire game.
---

Corrik posted...

Mason not claiming is literally the worst play this entire game.

I'm baffled how you can think this. Even right now we have Harris dead to rights so what purpose would be served by outing mason? Give scum more information for free?
---

Forceful_Dragon posted...

Corrik posted...

Mason not claiming is literally the worst play this entire game.

I'm baffled how you can think this. Even right now we have Harris dead to rights so what purpose would be served by outing mason? Give scum more information for free?

Clear yourself as town. Half the game is alrdy confirmed town. Like wow.
---

Corrik's trying to save himself lmao

Don't worry I gotcha buddy
---

Corrik posted...

Clear yourself as town. Half the game is alrdy confirmed town. Like wow.

Why is that a good thing RIGHT NOW? The mason will be JUST as cleared tomorrow. Or the next day.

No one is saying the mason should never ever claim. Or that they should let town lynch them first.

But yesterday or today? There is no benefit.
---

Don't end day early. Get info and make scum play
---

Worst play was plum suiciding to save eaed and damning half his team imo
---

Came in here prepared to pressure Shad today and this happens... Looks like I absolutely nailed scum D1, at least.

Don't really want to hammer already, especially when it's the day I can be most active. I've done little enough as it is since D2. I'll do it if we know that we'll start D5 this evening, though, would rather not have so many short days and normal length nights in a row.

What's weird to me is that killing Shad basically guarantees Pirate's death. Which leads me to believe they either didn't know his role (but in which case why him over someone else unclaimed like me or Bell?), and/or they really needed him out of the way to stand a chance. Might hint towards Tange as the last scum? But Tange having a bit less pressure on him is less valuable than Pirate probably staying alive an extra while, so I don't think that's right either, at least not for those reasons. They probably just rolescanned him as jailer or something and needed it out the way.

FD, why did you vote PJ at first? Jailer and BG are compatible roles. Doctor and Jailer are not.
---

morning kids.

yeah let's not hammer, mzero is right.

corrik I remembered no. 3.

you want that Mason claim NOW!!! Because you cant counter it and the more confirmed town you can kill early the better chance of being in a 3 or 4some with a better chance of winning.

Corrik posted...

It kind of is why Sbell not being the last scum is hard to get to over Sultan. He keeps trying to gauge interest in my mislynch all game. Literally with the argument, hey "what is the chances that Corrik just offered up every single teammate to be the last scum left with 3 mislynches needed to win while confirming half the game town"

Hmmm.

I am not gaugin interest in your "mislynch". I like how you worded that though. and I don't know your scum game corrik, that's all wifom. and you would have only tanked your team after they tanked themselves.
---

How am I not dead yet?
---

Because people want to idle out the game to kill interest. There is literally nothing to be said same as yesterday unless people want to mass claim.

The last scum is probably Sultan. Nothing more to discuss here.

I feel like me and Mzero have had to hold a lot of people by the hand this game. = /
---

@MZero11
@DoubleTangicide

Hammer so we can maybe get this game back up tonight.
---

Corrik posted...

Because people want to idle out the game to kill interest. There is literally nothing to be said same as yesterday unless people want to mass claim.

The last scum is probably Sultan. Nothing more to discuss here.

I feel like me and Mzero have had to hold a lot of people by the hand this game. = /

Huh... ok... are you holding my hand in the game?
---

Pirate_Harris posted...

Corrik posted...

Because people want to idle out the game to kill interest. There is literally nothing to be said same as yesterday unless people want to mass claim.

The last scum is probably Sultan. Nothing more to discuss here.

I feel like me and Mzero have had to hold a lot of people by the hand this game. = /

Huh... ok... are you holding my hand in the game?

No cuz you are scum. We are holding town's hands.
---

Corrik posted...

Pirate_Harris posted...

Corrik posted...

Because people want to idle out the game to kill interest. There is literally nothing to be said same as yesterday unless people want to mass claim.

The last scum is probably Sultan. Nothing more to discuss here.

I feel like me and Mzero have had to hold a lot of people by the hand this game. = /

Huh... ok... are you holding my hand in the game?

No cuz you are scum. We are holding town's hands.

Probably a good idea... no one would expect scum corrik to hold scum pirates hand at all
---

And the reason we arent hammering is because 1 town will die tonight and they ha e the right to add all the info they desire, mainly, FD will be dead because hes the one with the most exp. left. (imo anyway)

##unvote

to prevent the hammer for now.
---

The only thing preventing people adding more info are the people themselves. I doubt we'll know anything tomorrow we didn't already know today, so there's not much point in hammering.

Pirate's wifom is annoying me

Corrik, was the entire argument on Sultan being scum that he isn't one of your "cleared" and that Plum's actions hinted that the scum team had a few noobs on it?
---

Sheep007 posted...

The only thing preventing people adding more info are the people themselves. I doubt we'll know anything tomorrow we didn't already know today, so there's not much point in hammering.

Pirate's wifom is annoying me

Corrik, was the entire argument on Sultan being scum that he isn't one of your "cleared" and that Plum's actions hinted that the scum team had a few noobs on it?

Last scum is sbell or sultan. Sultan has went radio silent for awhile now since scum got steamrolled. Plum said they have "the worst newbs". Plum refused to vote Sultan end of day 1 with eaed in trouble.

Sbell has been all over the place and is either being absolutely god awful as town or is scum. He has lied repeatedly about his scum play from previous games. He has tried to argue off of lynches which were scum repeatedly. He has tried to cloud the game up and make it less easy as it is all game. Plum refused to vote him end of Day 1 to help eaed.
---

day has been up for 12 hours and its saturday morning. plenty of time to give people a chance to wake up.

personally I'm going to do some rereading a but later today after some activities with the kids.

I'm slowly selling myself on corrik but it would be foolish to not reread everyone else still alive.
---

Sultan was probably my biggest townread D1 but he's slowly slipped down the list, partially due to his lack of doing anything. Might be a motivation issue with little to do the last few days. Could also be demoralized scum, for similar reasons.
---

Corrik posted...

He has lied repeatedly about his scum play from previous games.

not remember something is not a lie. I dont ha e memory for random mafia games, I have more important things in my life.

Corrik posted...

He has tried to argue off of lynches which were scum repeatedly.

this is a lie.

Corrik posted...

He has tried to cloud the game up and make it less easy as it is all game

this is a matter of opinion. you dont like the way I play the game, dont sign up for games I sign up for.

Corrik posted...

Plum refused to vote him end of Day 1 to help eaed.

I was never a lynch risk, a vote on me would have been stupid. and plums interactions with me are no where near as bad as your interactions with pirate.
---

Sheep how was my performance overall?
---

Pirate_Harris posted...

Sheep how was my performance overall?

Bad D1, would've lynched you if I thought I could get anyone else to. Did honestly think you were town after your reaction to Corrik's fake D2 and you didn't do much D3, so could've definitely been worse overall. Better than the noob from last game.
---

Obellisk posted...

I was never a lynch risk, a vote on me would have been stupid

I take issue to this. If I recall correctly, you had 2 votes not long before deadline and at a similar point Ed had 3 votes. Scare was on less votes coming up to deadline iirc, he shouldn't have been a lynch risk following your logic.
---

Sheep007 posted...

Pirate_Harris posted...

Sheep how was my performance overall?

Bad D1, would've lynched you if I thought I could get anyone else to. Did honestly think you were town after your reaction to Corrik's fake D2 and you didn't do much D3, so could've definitely been worse overall. Better than the noob from last game.

Thanks... I got to learn a lot in this game
---

Sheep007 posted...

Obellisk posted...

I was never a lynch risk, a vote on me would have been stupid

I take issue to this. If I recall correctly, you had 2 votes not long before deadline and at a similar point Ed had 3 votes. Scare was on less votes coming up to deadline iirc, he shouldn't have been a lynch risk following your logic.

Sbell and Sultan were both at 2 while eaed was at 3 at points. He is just lying. Surprising.
---

Corrik posted...

Sheep007 posted...

Obellisk posted...

I was never a lynch risk, a vote on me would have been stupid

I take issue to this. If I recall correctly, you had 2 votes not long before deadline and at a similar point Ed had 3 votes. Scare was on less votes coming up to deadline iirc, he shouldn't have been a lynch risk following your logic.

Sbell and Sultan were both at 2 while eaed was at 3 at points. He is just lying. Surprising.

I'd like to point out that being wrong and lying are not the same. the more you try to misconstrue the worse you actually make yourself look.

I wasnt here end of day 1 really. and I never considered myself at risk.

and giving me negative Mark's cause scum who never said one bad word against me all day wouldnt vote me is fucking stupid.
---

Votals (through post #188)
[3] Pirate - (Corrik), PJ, FD, Corrik, (SBell)
[1] FD - Pirate
[0] Corrik - (Pirate)
[0] PJ - (FD)
[0] Tange - (Pirate)
[0] SBell - (Pirate)

With 9 alive, it takes 5 to lynch. Day ends on September 16th at 10:00 PM.
---

Bleh. Feels like there's no point in refraining from hammering at this point if the rest of the day is like this. I'll just do it if we get 24 hours into the day and nothing new happens. Doesn't help that the vast, vast majority of action is well after I'm asleep (particularly around the start of days).
---

hey sheep, rank all remaining players from towniest to sxummiest. I'll be around in like 2 to 3 hours for good.
---

Opinions on who to BG?

I'm surprised you still suspect Corrik after all this time sbell. It would be a very strange play of him trying to keep pirate of all people alive while gunning directly for plum and eaed?
---

pjbasis posted...

Opinions on who to BG?

I'm surprised you still suspect Corrik after all this time sbell. It would be a very strange play of him trying to keep pirate of all people alive while gunning directly for plum and eaed?

Hey pj who do you want to bg?
---

I don't know after you flip I almost don't want to use it cause I'm like confirmed and all and it might be dumb to stop a night kill on someone not confirmed.

But then they might just shoot MVP corrik
---

I think corrik is giving away that he's the actual mason and he's trying to trick the last scum into claiming it early imoooo
---

PJ they are going to kill you no matter what. It doesn't matter who you BG. You are dead, bud.
---

aw phooey
---

pjbasis posted...

aw phooey

So much for confirmed town
---

Obellisk posted...

hey sheep, rank all remaining players from towniest to sxummiest.

PJ
MZero
FD
Corrik
Sultan
SBell
Tange

PJ is basically confirmed town, MZero voted Ed where there was no real reason for scum to do so. I'm barely considering those two as possible scum any more. FD's behaviour in regards to Ed is also unlikely to come from scum, imo. Corrik's done an absolutely insane job of coaching Pirate if he's scum. However, the problem is, he's Corrik. That's honestly a possibility, however remote. I'd still argue that he's solidly town, though. Aside from a few spats he's been a lot better since the middle of D2.

I'd probably say that the final scum is from the three of you at the bottom, even though I don't feel dreadful about any of you. You've been very active (probably the most of, perhaps I'm noticing it more because you're around at the times I am, but still) and actually trying to get things to happen, which is obviously pro-town. However, I'm not getting the same obvious town vibes as I would last game. Honestly, you're there because I have a bunch of town reads, and there's not many left I'd want to lynch.

Sultan would also be a town read normally. His D1 gave me screaming town vibes. Problem is literally nothing he's done since has. Hopefully I can narrow this down afterwards.

Tange is my strongest remaining scumread. I was thinking he was likely town, with Shad and the scum we've already lynched all calling him scum. I thought he was the one they were trying to push the lynch onto. On second thought, I doubt that there was ever going to be any switch onto Tange, and scum knew that. There was plenty of wifom surrounding Tange from all the scum who we've basically nailed up to this point. I wouldn't be shocked if that was all an attempt to make him look better. He's done even less than last game, and hasn't had the excuse of being scanned as town this game. I'd say he's a moderately confident scumread.

pjbasis posted...

I think corrik is giving away that he's the actual mason and he's trying to trick the last scum into claiming it early imoooo

Shhhh we don't tell them that
---

Can I get a list from you too, SBell?
---