Current Events > Guy 3 just said The Last Jedi is better than Rogue One

Topic List	Page List: 1
Muffinz0rz 04/17/18 1:10:53 PM #1:	remember this is the same guy who said Fantastic Beasts is a Harry Potter movie smfh --- Not removing this until Pat Benatar is in Super Smash Bros. (Started 8/31/2010) 2018 NFLB Summersim (1-3): https://i.imgur.com/7cjNtgQ.png <cite>Muffinz0rz posted [p:899815958] in Guy 3 just... [t:76525453]...</cite> <quote>remember this is the same guy who said Fantastic Beasts is a Harry Potter movie smfh</quote> ... Copied to Clipboard!
Ilove4chan 04/17/18 1:11:19 PM #2:	okay --- i actually don't love 4chan NYM - PM me for LL/ETI <cite>Ilove4chan posted [p:899815984] in Guy 3 just... [t:76525453]...</cite> <quote>okay</quote> ... Copied to Clipboard!
Muffinz0rz 04/17/18 3:58:13 PM #3:	care --- Not removing this until Pat Benatar is in Super Smash Bros. (Started 8/31/2010) 2018 NFLB Summersim (1-3): https://i.imgur.com/7cjNtgQ.png <cite>Muffinz0rz posted [p:899825771] in Guy 3 just... [t:76525453]...</cite> <quote>care</quote> ... Copied to Clipboard!
K181 04/17/18 3:59:09 PM #4:	I agree with him then. On TLJ, I mean. Haven't seen Fantastic Beasts, so I can't say if it's good or not. --- The poster formerly known as Kakarot181: July 2, 2002 - March 14, 2012. Irregardless, for all intensive purposes, I could care less. <cite>K181 posted [p:899825823] in Guy 3 just... [t:76525453]...</cite> <quote>I agree with him then. On TLJ, I mean. Haven't seen Fantastic Beasts, so I can't say if it's good or not.</quote> ... Copied to Clipboard!
Old NoiseTank 04/17/18 3:59:35 PM #5:	but it is. --- Grim Reaper: "Your time has come" Xsquader: "sir whats your badge number?" <cite>Old NoiseTank posted [p:899825845] in Guy 3 just... [t:76525453]...</cite> <quote>but it is.</quote> ... Copied to Clipboard!
#6	Post #6 was unavailable or deleted.
Kitt 04/17/18 4:04:26 PM #7:	Fantastic Beasts is a Harry Potter movie Is it not? --- http://i.imgur.com/pmc9XsI.gif http://i.imgur.com/LkrRVe2.gifv http://i.imgur.com/Dp03g3y.jpg Cute? B**, I'm adorable. <cite>Kitt posted [p:899826118] in Guy 3 just... [t:76525453]...</cite> <quote><quote>Fantastic Beasts is a Harry Potter movie</quote> Is it not?</quote> ... Copied to Clipboard!
HylianFox 04/17/18 4:05:09 PM #8:	Rogue One was very Shakespearean in that ~~everybody dies~~ --- I like my beer cold, my TV loud, and my homosexuals FUH-LAMING! - Homer Simpson i.imgur.com/a2EzoIs.gif i.imgur.com/rPcGRiP.gif <cite>HylianFox posted [p:899826164] in Guy 3 just... [t:76525453]...</cite> <quote>Rogue One was very Shakespearean in that everybody dies</quote> ... Copied to Clipboard!
DoGCyN 04/17/18 4:06:46 PM #9:	But Rogue One was actually good. --- --- <cite>DoGCyN posted [p:899826244] in Guy 3 just... [t:76525453]...</cite> <quote>But Rogue One was actually good.</quote> ... Copied to Clipboard!
Muffinz0rz 04/17/18 4:07:12 PM #10:	Kitt posted... remember this is the same guy who said Fantastic Beasts is a Harry Potter movie Is it not? No, it's not. It takes place in the wizarding world, a.k.a the same universe in which Harry Potter exists, but it is not a Harry Potter movie. --- Not removing this until Pat Benatar is in Super Smash Bros. (Started 8/31/2010) 2018 NFLB Summersim (1-3): https://i.imgur.com/7cjNtgQ.png <cite>Muffinz0rz posted [p:899826269] in Guy 3 just... [t:76525453]...</cite> <quote><cite>Kitt posted...</cite> <quote><quote>remember this is the same guy who said Fantastic Beasts is a Harry Potter movie</quote> Is it not?</quote> No, it's not. It takes place in the wizarding world, a.k.a the same universe in which Harry Potter exists, but it is not a Harry Potter movie.</quote> ... Copied to Clipboard!
Kitt 04/17/18 4:08:03 PM #11:	Muffinz0rz posted... Kitt posted... remember this is the same guy who said Fantastic Beasts is a Harry Potter movie Is it not? It takes place in the wizarding world, a.k.a the same universe in which Harry Potter exists Well then. --- http://i.imgur.com/pmc9XsI.gif http://i.imgur.com/LkrRVe2.gifv http://i.imgur.com/Dp03g3y.jpg Cute? B**, I'm adorable. <cite>Kitt posted [p:899826318] in Guy 3 just... [t:76525453]...</cite> <quote><cite>Muffinz0rz posted...</cite> <quote><cite>Kitt posted...</cite> <quote><quote>remember this is the same guy who said Fantastic Beasts is a Harry Potter movie</quote> Is it not?</quote> It takes place in the wizarding world, a.k.a the same universe in which Harry Potter exists</quote> Well then.</quote> ... Copied to Clipboard!
NibeIungsnarf 04/17/18 4:08:15 PM #12:	Muffinz0rz posted... Kitt posted... remember this is the same guy who said Fantastic Beasts is a Harry Potter movie Is it not? No, it's not. It takes place in the wizarding world, a.k.a the same universe in which Harry Potter exists, but it is not a Harry Potter movie. That seems like a distinction without meaning. <cite>NibeIungsnarf posted [p:899826328] in Guy 3 just... [t:76525453]...</cite> <quote><cite>Muffinz0rz posted...</cite> <quote><cite>Kitt posted...</cite> <quote><quote>remember this is the same guy who said Fantastic Beasts is a Harry Potter movie</quote> Is it not?</quote> No, it's not. It takes place in the wizarding world, a.k.a the same universe in which Harry Potter exists, but it is not a Harry Potter movie.</quote> That seems like a distinction without meaning.</quote> ... Copied to Clipboard!
Stooge1969 04/17/18 4:10:53 PM #13:	they're both turds <cite>Stooge1969 posted [p:899826466] in Guy 3 just... [t:76525453]...</cite> <quote>they're both turds</quote> ... Copied to Clipboard!
Muffinz0rz 04/17/18 4:20:02 PM #14:	NibeIungsnarf posted... Muffinz0rz posted... Kitt posted... remember this is the same guy who said Fantastic Beasts is a Harry Potter movie Is it not? No, it's not. It takes place in the wizarding world, a.k.a the same universe in which Harry Potter exists, but it is not a Harry Potter movie. That seems like a distinction without meaning. Prove to me that it's a Harry Potter movie. --- Not removing this until Pat Benatar is in Super Smash Bros. (Started 8/31/2010) 2018 NFLB Summersim (1-3): https://i.imgur.com/7cjNtgQ.png <cite>Muffinz0rz posted [p:899826985] in Guy 3 just... [t:76525453]...</cite> <quote><cite>NibeIungsnarf posted...</cite> <quote><cite>Muffinz0rz posted...</cite> <quote><cite>Kitt posted...</cite> <quote><quote>remember this is the same guy who said Fantastic Beasts is a Harry Potter movie</quote> Is it not?</quote> No, it's not. It takes place in the wizarding world, a.k.a the same universe in which Harry Potter exists, but it is not a Harry Potter movie.</quote> That seems like a distinction without meaning.</quote> Prove to me that it's a Harry Potter movie.</quote> ... Copied to Clipboard!
Kitt 04/17/18 4:20:41 PM #15:	NibeIungsnarf posted... Muffinz0rz posted... Kitt posted... remember this is the same guy who said Fantastic Beasts is a Harry Potter movie Is it not? No, it's not. It takes place in the wizarding world, a.k.a the same universe in which Harry Potter exists, but it is not a Harry Potter movie. That seems like a distinction without meaning. Sweet Tooth is not his name, it's the name of his vehicle. The clown is Needles Kane. Kappa. --- http://i.imgur.com/pmc9XsI.gif http://i.imgur.com/LkrRVe2.gifv http://i.imgur.com/Dp03g3y.jpg Cute? B**, I'm adorable. <cite>Kitt posted [p:899827030] in Guy 3 just... [t:76525453]...</cite> <quote><cite>NibeIungsnarf posted...</cite> <quote><cite>Muffinz0rz posted...</cite> <quote><cite>Kitt posted...</cite> <quote><quote>remember this is the same guy who said Fantastic Beasts is a Harry Potter movie</quote> Is it not?</quote> No, it's not. It takes place in the wizarding world, a.k.a the same universe in which Harry Potter exists, but it is not a Harry Potter movie.</quote> That seems like a distinction without meaning.</quote> Sweet Tooth is not his name, it's the name of his vehicle. The clown is Needles Kane. Kappa.</quote> ... Copied to Clipboard!
Kitt 04/17/18 4:22:32 PM #16:	Muffinz0rz posted... NibeIungsnarf posted... Muffinz0rz posted... Kitt posted... remember this is the same guy who said Fantastic Beasts is a Harry Potter movie Is it not? No, it's not. It takes place in the wizarding world, a.k.a the same universe in which Harry Potter exists, but it is not a Harry Potter movie. That seems like a distinction without meaning. Prove to me that it's a Harry Potter movie. Because when people refer to it as a "Harry Potter" movie, chances are, they're referring to Harry Potter as an IP and not the character... --- http://i.imgur.com/pmc9XsI.gif http://i.imgur.com/LkrRVe2.gifv http://i.imgur.com/Dp03g3y.jpg Cute? B**, I'm adorable. <cite>Kitt posted [p:899827140] in Guy 3 just... [t:76525453]...</cite> <quote><cite>Muffinz0rz posted...</cite> <quote><cite>NibeIungsnarf posted...</cite> <quote><cite>Muffinz0rz posted...</cite> <quote><cite>Kitt posted...</cite> <quote><quote>remember this is the same guy who said Fantastic Beasts is a Harry Potter movie</quote> Is it not?</quote> No, it's not. It takes place in the wizarding world, a.k.a the same universe in which Harry Potter exists, but it is not a Harry Potter movie.</quote> That seems like a distinction without meaning.</quote> Prove to me that it's a Harry Potter movie.</quote> Because when people refer to it as a "Harry Potter" movie, chances are, they're referring to Harry Potter as an IP and not the character...</quote> ... Copied to Clipboard!
hollow_shrine 04/17/18 4:22:49 PM #17:	I'm not in love with either, TBH. --- Whatever happened to standards? Whatever happened to bare minimums? https://imgtc.com/i/7UnK3hx.jpg <cite>hollow_shrine posted [p:899827159] in Guy 3 just... [t:76525453]...</cite> <quote>I'm not in love with either, TBH.</quote> ... Copied to Clipboard!
NibeIungsnarf 04/17/18 4:23:03 PM #18:	Muffinz0rz posted... NibeIungsnarf posted... Muffinz0rz posted... Kitt posted... remember this is the same guy who said Fantastic Beasts is a Harry Potter movie Is it not? No, it's not. It takes place in the wizarding world, a.k.a the same universe in which Harry Potter exists, but it is not a Harry Potter movie. That seems like a distinction without meaning. Prove to me that it's a Harry Potter movie. Harry Potter is a franchise moniker. It's a movie in that franchise. This seems like a petty squabble. I don't care whether or not you call Fantastic Beasts a Harry Potter movie I just think it's petty to get your panties in a bunch that some people do. <cite>NibeIungsnarf posted [p:899827176] in Guy 3 just... [t:76525453]...</cite> <quote><cite>Muffinz0rz posted...</cite> <quote><cite>NibeIungsnarf posted...</cite> <quote><cite>Muffinz0rz posted...</cite> <quote><cite>Kitt posted...</cite> <quote><quote>remember this is the same guy who said Fantastic Beasts is a Harry Potter movie</quote> Is it not?</quote> No, it's not. It takes place in the wizarding world, a.k.a the same universe in which Harry Potter exists, but it is not a Harry Potter movie.</quote> That seems like a distinction without meaning.</quote> Prove to me that it's a Harry Potter movie.</quote> Harry Potter is a franchise moniker. It's a movie in that franchise. This seems like a petty squabble. I don't care whether or not you call Fantastic Beasts a Harry Potter movie I just think it's petty to get your panties in a bunch that some people do.</quote> ... Copied to Clipboard!
Doctor Foxx 04/17/18 4:28:31 PM #19:	NibeIungsnarf posted... Muffinz0rz posted... NibeIungsnarf posted... Muffinz0rz posted... Kitt posted... remember this is the same guy who said Fantastic Beasts is a Harry Potter movie Is it not? No, it's not. It takes place in the wizarding world, a.k.a the same universe in which Harry Potter exists, but it is not a Harry Potter movie. That seems like a distinction without meaning. Prove to me that it's a Harry Potter movie. Harry Potter is a franchise moniker. It's a movie in that franchise. This seems like a petty squabble. I don't care whether or not you call Fantastic Beasts a Harry Potter movie I just think it's petty to get your panties in a bunch that some people do. No doubt. It's a Harry Potter Universe movie, which was agreed, and anything more is pedantic. --- Never write off the Doctor! <cite>Doctor Foxx posted [p:899827461] in Guy 3 just... [t:76525453]...</cite> <quote><cite>NibeIungsnarf posted...</cite> <quote><cite>Muffinz0rz posted...</cite> <quote><cite>NibeIungsnarf posted...</cite> <quote><cite>Muffinz0rz posted...</cite> <quote><cite>Kitt posted...</cite> <quote><quote>remember this is the same guy who said Fantastic Beasts is a Harry Potter movie</quote> Is it not?</quote> No, it's not. It takes place in the wizarding world, a.k.a the same universe in which Harry Potter exists, but it is not a Harry Potter movie.</quote> That seems like a distinction without meaning.</quote> Prove to me that it's a Harry Potter movie.</quote> Harry Potter is a franchise moniker. It's a movie in that franchise. This seems like a petty squabble. I don't care whether or not you call Fantastic Beasts a Harry Potter movie I just think it's petty to get your panties in a bunch that some people do.</quote> No doubt. It's a Harry Potter Universe movie, which was agreed, and anything more is pedantic.</quote> ... Copied to Clipboard!
hollow_shrine 04/17/18 4:33:40 PM #20:	Think of it in terms of The Hobbit's relationship to the Lord of the Rings trilogy or the Silmarillion. There's no school. It's sixty years before the events of the novel. It's set in America instead of Britain. All of the cast members are adults instead of children and a handful of adults playing teachers. The only connection to Harry Potter comes from obscure backstory lore from the novels. Newt will write a magical zoology textbook that Harry will use for class in sixty years. The book and it's author will be name-dropped exactly once. And while all this drama is going down, Grindlewald is ramping up for the reign of terror, but is implied in the novel to start around this time in Europe. That's literally it. If JK Rowling hadn't written and sold a version of this book for charity purposes, the book and its title would be forgotten to all but the most attentive Harry Potter fans. Beyond that, this is a fantasy story set in industrial America. Unless you want to claim all magical stories set outside of medieval settings are Harry Potter stories, you have to concede that Fantastic Beasts is not a Harry Potter story in subject matter, casting, tone, or theming, but is merely Harry Potter adjacent. --- Whatever happened to standards? Whatever happened to bare minimums? https://imgtc.com/i/7UnK3hx.jpg <cite>hollow_shrine posted [p:899827749] in Guy 3 just... [t:76525453]...</cite> <quote>Think of it in terms of The Hobbit's relationship to the Lord of the Rings trilogy or the Silmarillion. There's no school. It's sixty years before the events of the novel. It's set in America instead of Britain. All of the cast members are adults instead of children and a handful of adults playing teachers. The only connection to Harry Potter comes from obscure backstory lore from the novels. Newt will write a magical zoology textbook that Harry will use for class in sixty years. The book and it's author will be name-dropped exactly once. And while all this drama is going down, Grindlewald is ramping up for the reign of terror, but is implied in the novel to start around this time in Europe. That's literally it. If JK Rowling hadn't written and sold a version of this book for charity purposes, the book and its title would be forgotten to all but the most attentive Harry Potter fans. Beyond that, this is a fantasy story set in industrial America. Unless you want to claim all magical stories set outside of medieval settings are Harry Potter stories, you have to concede that Fantastic Beasts is not a Harry Potter story in subject matter, casting, tone, or theming, but is merely Harry Potter adjacent.</quote> ... Copied to Clipboard!
Muffinz0rz 04/17/18 4:44:02 PM #21:	hollow_shrine posted... Think of it in terms of The Hobbit's relationship to the Lord of the Rings trilogy or the Silmarillion. There's no school. It's sixty years before the events of the novel. It's set in America instead of Britain. All of the cast members are adults instead of children and a handful of adults playing teachers. The only connection to Harry Potter comes from obscure backstory lore from the novels. Newt will write a magical zoology textbook that Harry will use for class in sixty years. The book and it's author will be name-dropped exactly once. And while all this drama is going down, Grindlewald is ramping up for the reign of terror, but is implied in the novel to start around this time in Europe. That's literally it. If JK Rowling hadn't written and sold a version of this book for charity purposes, the book and its title would be forgotten to all but the most attentive Harry Potter fans. Beyond that, this is a fantasy story set in industrial America. Unless you want to claim all magical stories set outside of medieval settings are Harry Potter stories, you have to concede that Fantastic Beasts is not a Harry Potter story in subject matter, casting, tone, or theming, but is merely Harry Potter adjacent. /topic --- Not removing this until Pat Benatar is in Super Smash Bros. (Started 8/31/2010) 2018 NFLB Summersim (1-3): https://i.imgur.com/7cjNtgQ.png <cite>Muffinz0rz posted [p:899828433] in Guy 3 just... [t:76525453]...</cite> <quote><cite>hollow_shrine posted...</cite> <quote>Think of it in terms of The Hobbit's relationship to the Lord of the Rings trilogy or the Silmarillion. There's no school. It's sixty years before the events of the novel. It's set in America instead of Britain. All of the cast members are adults instead of children and a handful of adults playing teachers. The only connection to Harry Potter comes from obscure backstory lore from the novels. Newt will write a magical zoology textbook that Harry will use for class in sixty years. The book and it's author will be name-dropped exactly once. And while all this drama is going down, Grindlewald is ramping up for the reign of terror, but is implied in the novel to start around this time in Europe. That's literally it. If JK Rowling hadn't written and sold a version of this book for charity purposes, the book and its title would be forgotten to all but the most attentive Harry Potter fans. Beyond that, this is a fantasy story set in industrial America. Unless you want to claim all magical stories set outside of medieval settings are Harry Potter stories, you have to concede that Fantastic Beasts is not a Harry Potter story in subject matter, casting, tone, or theming, but is merely Harry Potter adjacent.</quote> /topic</quote> ... Copied to Clipboard!
UnholyMudcrab 04/17/18 4:44:42 PM #22:	Most movies are better than Rogue One --- http://i.imgur.com/VeNBg.gif http://i.imgur.com/gd5jC8q.gif http://i.imgur.com/PKIy7.gif http://i.imgur.com/3p29JqP.gif <cite>UnholyMudcrab posted [p:899828464] in Guy 3 just... [t:76525453]...</cite> <quote>Most movies are better than Rogue One</quote> ... Copied to Clipboard!
#23	Post #23 was unavailable or deleted.
Raikuro 04/17/18 4:47:39 PM #24:	Your other topic he said it was technically a Harry Potter movie. Which it is. Technically. <cite>Raikuro posted [p:899828648] in Guy 3 just... [t:76525453]...</cite> <quote>Your other topic he said it was technically a Harry Potter movie. Which it is. Technically.</quote> ... Copied to Clipboard!
Muffinz0rz 04/17/18 4:49:09 PM #25:	Raikuro posted... Your other topic he said it was technically a Harry Potter movie. Right. Raikuro posted... Which it is. Technically. Wrong. --- Not removing this until Pat Benatar is in Super Smash Bros. (Started 8/31/2010) 2018 NFLB Summersim (1-3): https://i.imgur.com/7cjNtgQ.png <cite>Muffinz0rz posted [p:899828738] in Guy 3 just... [t:76525453]...</cite> <quote><cite>Raikuro posted...</cite> <quote>Your other topic he said it was technically a Harry Potter movie.</quote> Right. <cite>Raikuro posted...</cite> <quote>Which it is. Technically.</quote> Wrong.</quote> ... Copied to Clipboard!
HylianFox 04/17/18 5:01:01 PM #26:	hollow_shrine posted... There's no school. It's sixty years before the events of the novel. Pretty sure Hogwarts has been around since medieval times >__> --- I like my beer cold, my TV loud, and my homosexuals FUH-LAMING! - Homer Simpson i.imgur.com/a2EzoIs.gif i.imgur.com/rPcGRiP.gif <cite>HylianFox posted [p:899829410] in Guy 3 just... [t:76525453]...</cite> <quote><cite>hollow_shrine posted...</cite> <quote>There's no school. It's sixty years before the events of the novel.</quote> Pretty sure Hogwarts has been around since medieval times >__></quote> ... Copied to Clipboard!
Doctor Foxx 04/17/18 5:08:50 PM #27:	hollow_shrine posted... Think of it in terms of The Hobbit's relationship to the Lord of the Rings trilogy or the Silmarillion. There's no school. It's sixty years before the events of the novel. It's set in America instead of Britain. All of the cast members are adults instead of children and a handful of adults playing teachers. The only connection to Harry Potter comes from obscure backstory lore from the novels. Newt will write a magical zoology textbook that Harry will use for class in sixty years. The book and it's author will be name-dropped exactly once. And while all this drama is going down, Grindlewald is ramping up for the reign of terror, but is implied in the novel to start around this time in Europe. That's literally it. If JK Rowling hadn't written and sold a version of this book for charity purposes, the book and its title would be forgotten to all but the most attentive Harry Potter fans. Beyond that, this is a fantasy story set in industrial America. Unless you want to claim all magical stories set outside of medieval settings are Harry Potter stories, you have to concede that Fantastic Beasts is not a Harry Potter story in subject matter, casting, tone, or theming, but is merely Harry Potter adjacent. uhh Professor Binns said the school is over 1,000 years old. do you even understand the lore my friend --- Never write off the Doctor! <cite>Doctor Foxx posted [p:899829858] in Guy 3 just... [t:76525453]...</cite> <quote><cite>hollow_shrine posted...</cite> <quote>Think of it in terms of The Hobbit's relationship to the Lord of the Rings trilogy or the Silmarillion. There's no school. It's sixty years before the events of the novel. It's set in America instead of Britain. All of the cast members are adults instead of children and a handful of adults playing teachers. The only connection to Harry Potter comes from obscure backstory lore from the novels. Newt will write a magical zoology textbook that Harry will use for class in sixty years. The book and it's author will be name-dropped exactly once. And while all this drama is going down, Grindlewald is ramping up for the reign of terror, but is implied in the novel to start around this time in Europe. That's literally it. If JK Rowling hadn't written and sold a version of this book for charity purposes, the book and its title would be forgotten to all but the most attentive Harry Potter fans. Beyond that, this is a fantasy story set in industrial America. Unless you want to claim all magical stories set outside of medieval settings are Harry Potter stories, you have to concede that Fantastic Beasts is not a Harry Potter story in subject matter, casting, tone, or theming, but is merely Harry Potter adjacent.</quote> uhh Professor Binns said the school is over 1,000 years old. do you even understand the lore my friend</quote> ... Copied to Clipboard!
sktgamer_13dude 04/17/18 5:11:17 PM #28:	The second one literally name drops Dumbledore in the trailer. Its a Harry Potter universe movie which means its basically a Harry Potter movie. --- http://i.imgur.com/jWVrg9U.gif http://i.imgur.com/g2efUtT.jpg http://i.imgur.com/5dOwhaP.jpg http://i.imgur.com/LVdqu8J.gif Go Cougs and M's #DI4B <cite>sktgamer_13dude posted [p:899830016] in Guy 3 just... [t:76525453]...</cite> <quote>The second one literally name drops Dumbledore in the trailer. Its a Harry Potter universe movie which means its basically a Harry Potter movie.</quote> ... Copied to Clipboard!
Kitt 04/17/18 5:21:13 PM #29:	hollow_shrine posted... Unless you want to claim all magical stories set outside of medieval settings are Harry Potter stories, you have to concede that Fantastic Beasts is not a Harry Potter story in subject matter, casting, tone, or theming, but is merely Harry Potter adjacent. NibeIungsnarf posted... Harry Potter is a franchise moniker. It's a movie in that franchise. This seems like a petty squabble. I don't care whether or not you call Fantastic Beasts a Harry Potter movie I just think it's petty to get your panties in a bunch that some people do. Kitt posted... Because when people refer to it as a "Harry Potter" movie, chances are, they're referring to Harry Potter as an IP and not the character... --- http://i.imgur.com/pmc9XsI.gif http://i.imgur.com/LkrRVe2.gifv http://i.imgur.com/Dp03g3y.jpg Cute? B**, I'm adorable. <cite>Kitt posted [p:899830539] in Guy 3 just... [t:76525453]...</cite> <quote><cite>hollow_shrine posted...</cite> <quote>Unless you want to claim all magical stories set outside of medieval settings are Harry Potter stories, you have to concede that Fantastic Beasts is not a Harry Potter story in subject matter, casting, tone, or theming, but is merely Harry Potter adjacent.</quote> <cite>NibeIungsnarf posted...</cite> <quote>Harry Potter is a franchise moniker. It's a movie in that franchise. This seems like a petty squabble. I don't care whether or not you call Fantastic Beasts a Harry Potter movie I just think it's petty to get your panties in a bunch that some people do.</quote> <cite>Kitt posted...</cite> <quote>Because when people refer to it as a "Harry Potter" movie, chances are, they're referring to Harry Potter as an IP and not the character...</quote></quote> ... Copied to Clipboard!
hollow_shrine 04/17/18 5:25:19 PM #30:	HylianFox posted... hollow_shrine posted... There's no school. It's sixty years before the events of the novel. Pretty sure Hogwarts has been around since medieval times >__> The name of the school Hogwarts is mentioned exactly once in Fantastic Beasts, when it's revealed Newt was apparently expelled and never graduated. The existence of Hogwarts is not particularly relevant to the setting and plot of Fantastic Beasts. Doctor Foxx posted... Professor Binns said the school is over 1,000 years old. Yes, but Professor Bins is on the other side of the Atlantic Ocean for duration of this movie. He's not mentioned at all in Fantastic Beasts which makes sense because he's not particularly relevant to the plot here. Were you to simply see Fantastic Beasts you wouldn't know of the existence of a Professor Bins at all. sktgamer_13dude posted... The second one literally name drops Dumbledore in the trailer. Its a Harry Potter universe movie which means its basically a Harry Potter movie. If anything that means the sequel, The Crimes of Grindlewald, is a Harry Potter movie, not Fantastic Beasts. That's like claiming the Hobbit is a Lord of the Rings book because Gandalf and Bilbo make an appearance in both books. I would still contest that it's not though, for all of the above mentioned reasons (tone, setting, timing, cast, theme, plot, etc.). I've got to say, I don't think we're doing a very good job reading each others posts right now, so much as rushing to the end of things so we can type out our response. We're not talking to one another so much as we're talking at them. Perhaps slow down, and re-read posts before writing your reply. --- Whatever happened to standards? Whatever happened to bare minimums? https://imgtc.com/i/7UnK3hx.jpg <cite>hollow_shrine posted [p:899830763] in Guy 3 just... [t:76525453]...</cite> <quote><cite>HylianFox posted...</cite> <quote><cite>hollow_shrine posted...</cite> <quote>There's no school. It's sixty years before the events of the novel.</quote> Pretty sure Hogwarts has been around since medieval times >__></quote> The name of the school Hogwarts is mentioned exactly once in Fantastic Beasts, when it's revealed Newt was apparently expelled and never graduated. The existence of Hogwarts is not particularly relevant to the setting and plot of Fantastic Beasts. <cite>Doctor Foxx posted...</cite> <quote>Professor Binns said the school is over 1,000 years old.</quote> Yes, but Professor Bins is on the other side of the Atlantic Ocean for duration of this movie. He's not mentioned at all in Fantastic Beasts which makes sense because he's not particularly relevant to the plot here. Were you to simply see Fantastic Beasts you wouldn't know of the existence of a Professor Bins at all. <cite>sktgamer_13dude posted...</cite> <quote>The second one literally name drops Dumbledore in the trailer. Its a Harry Potter universe movie which means its basically a Harry Potter movie.</quote> If anything that means the sequel, The Crimes of Grindlewald, is a Harry Potter movie, not Fantastic Beasts. That's like claiming the Hobbit is a Lord of the Rings book because Gandalf and Bilbo make an appearance in both books. I would still contest that it's not though, for all of the above mentioned reasons (tone, setting, timing, cast, theme, plot, etc.). I've got to say, I don't think we're doing a very good job reading each others posts right now, so much as rushing to the end of things so we can type out our response. We're not talking to one another so much as we're talking at them. Perhaps slow down, and re-read posts before writing your reply.</quote> ... Copied to Clipboard!
Doctor Foxx 04/17/18 5:43:41 PM #31:	hollow_shrine posted... If anything that means the sequel, The Crimes of Grindlewald, is a Harry Potter movie, not Fantastic Beasts. That's like claiming the Hobbit is a Lord of the Rings book because Gandalf and Bilbo make an appearance in both books. I would still contest that it's not though, for all of the above mentioned reasons (tone, setting, timing, cast, theme, plot, etc.). The Star wars prequels are not star wars films because they don't take place on tattooine or have a death star or Luke or Leia For that matter you'd have to say Rogue One is not a Star Wars film Do you see the absurdity --- Never write off the Doctor! <cite>Doctor Foxx posted [p:899831844] in Guy 3 just... [t:76525453]...</cite> <quote><cite>hollow_shrine posted...</cite> <quote>If anything that means the sequel, The Crimes of Grindlewald, is a Harry Potter movie, not Fantastic Beasts. That's like claiming the Hobbit is a Lord of the Rings book because Gandalf and Bilbo make an appearance in both books. I would still contest that it's not though, for all of the above mentioned reasons (tone, setting, timing, cast, theme, plot, etc.).</quote> The Star wars prequels are not star wars films because they don't take place on tattooine or have a death star or Luke or Leia For that matter you'd have to say Rogue One is not a Star Wars film Do you see the absurdity</quote> ... Copied to Clipboard!
prince_leo 04/17/18 5:50:24 PM #32:	hollow_shrine posted... Unless you want to claim all magical stories set outside of medieval settings are Harry Potter stories, no, just the ones that reference Hogwarts, muggles, Dumbledore, wand specific spells like 'expelliarmus' etc. --- https://imgur.com/uHUvpSH http://error1355.com/ce/prince_leo.html <cite>prince_leo posted [p:899832245] in Guy 3 just... [t:76525453]...</cite> <quote><cite>hollow_shrine posted...</cite> <quote>Unless you want to claim all magical stories set outside of medieval settings are Harry Potter stories, </quote> no, just the ones that reference Hogwarts, muggles, Dumbledore, wand specific spells like 'expelliarmus' etc.</quote> ... Copied to Clipboard!
BruceWayneJr 04/17/18 6:05:03 PM #33:	Doctor Foxx posted... The Star wars prequels are not star wars films because they don't take place on tattooine or have a death star or Luke or Leia Heh, Tattooine is in all three films, a visual representation of the Death Star concept is in AOTC, and baby Luke and Leia are in the end of ROTS. But of course Fantastic Beasts is a Harry Potter film. TC's just weird. --- He might be the president, but it's not his country. <cite>BruceWayneJr posted [p:899833048] in Guy 3 just... [t:76525453]...</cite> <quote><cite>Doctor Foxx posted...</cite> <quote>The Star wars prequels are not star wars films because they don't take place on tattooine or have a death star or Luke or Leia</quote> Heh, Tattooine is in all three films, a visual representation of the Death Star concept is in AOTC, and baby Luke and Leia are in the end of ROTS. But of course Fantastic Beasts is a Harry Potter film. TC's just weird.</quote> ... Copied to Clipboard!
Doctor Foxx 04/17/18 6:12:48 PM #34:	BruceWayneJr posted... Doctor Foxx posted... The Star wars prequels are not star wars films because they don't take place on tattooine or have a death star or Luke or Leia Heh, Tattooine is in all three prequels, a visual representation of the Death Star concept is in AOTC, and baby Luke and Leia are in the end of ROTS. But of course Fantastic Beasts is a Harry Potter film. TC's just weird. You're right. I've blanked on some of the prequels stuff References to the wizarding world are in the fantastic beasts film. If Rogue One is a Star Wars film, Fantastic Beasts is a Harry Potter film (even though it's not part of the specific Harry Potter series) --- Never write off the Doctor! <cite>Doctor Foxx posted [p:899833462] in Guy 3 just... [t:76525453]...</cite> <quote><cite>BruceWayneJr posted...</cite> <quote><cite>Doctor Foxx posted...</cite> <quote>The Star wars prequels are not star wars films because they don't take place on tattooine or have a death star or Luke or Leia</quote> Heh, Tattooine is in all three prequels, a visual representation of the Death Star concept is in AOTC, and baby Luke and Leia are in the end of ROTS. But of course Fantastic Beasts is a Harry Potter film. TC's just weird.</quote> You're right. I've blanked on some of the prequels stuff References to the wizarding world are in the fantastic beasts film. If Rogue One is a Star Wars film, Fantastic Beasts is a Harry Potter film (even though it's not part of the specific Harry Potter series)</quote> ... Copied to Clipboard!
prince_leo 04/17/18 6:18:02 PM #35:	Doctor Foxx posted... References to the wizarding world are in the fantastic beasts film. If Rogue One is a Star Wars film, Fantastic Beasts is a Harry Potter film (even though it's not part of the specific Harry Potter series) exactly. being a stickler over people using "Harry Potter" as a brand name and not as a character is fucking weird which I suppose is why they've come up with "Wizarding World" to help with those people same as the comparison to the Hobbit and LOTR films. when people talk about them and call the Hobbit trilogy "Lord of the Rings films" they're not being unclear, they're just not using "Middle-Earth films" instead --- https://imgur.com/uHUvpSH http://error1355.com/ce/prince_leo.html <cite>prince_leo posted [p:899833777] in Guy 3 just... [t:76525453]...</cite> <quote><cite>Doctor Foxx posted...</cite> <quote>References to the wizarding world are in the fantastic beasts film. If Rogue One is a Star Wars film, Fantastic Beasts is a Harry Potter film (even though it's not part of the specific Harry Potter series)</quote> exactly. being a stickler over people using "Harry Potter" as a brand name and not as a character is fucking weird which I suppose is why they've come up with "Wizarding World" to help with those people same as the comparison to the Hobbit and LOTR films. when people talk about them and call the Hobbit trilogy "Lord of the Rings films" they're not being unclear, they're just not using "Middle-Earth films" instead</quote> ... Copied to Clipboard!
Topic List	Page List: 1

Current Events > Guy 3 just said The Last Jedi is better than Rogue One (+) Yeah! (+)

Current Events > Guy 3 just said The Last Jedi is better than Rogue One