Current Events > How close is too close for Disney remakes?

Topic List	Page List: 1
Bass_X0 03/08/23 4:31:40 PM #1:	Do an accurate shot for shot remake and people complain. Make it completely new and different and people complain. Wheres the middle that would make everybody happy? --- "Well, it's not a bad game. It's made by Capcom, so how could it?" ~ AVGN <cite>Bass_X0 posted [p:972041780] in How close ... [t:80372788]...</cite> <quote>Do an accurate shot for shot remake and people complain.Make it completely new and different and people complain.Wheres the middle that would make everybody happy?</quote> ... Copied to Clipboard!
MICHALECOLE 03/08/23 4:32:33 PM #2:	Everybody will always complain <cite>MICHALECOLE posted [p:972041799] in How close ... [t:80372788]...</cite> <quote>Everybody will always complain </quote> ... Copied to Clipboard!
Supersex420 03/08/23 4:32:54 PM #3:	People want OC as memorable as a old stuff --- Oh- I sometimes make up all of my lines on the spot But I will always give what I got - KKB <cite>Supersex420 posted [p:972041803] in How close ... [t:80372788]...</cite> <quote>People want OC as memorable as a old stuff</quote> ... Copied to Clipboard!
Unsuprised_Pika 03/08/23 4:33:09 PM #4:	Not remaking lush animated films in live action at all. --- I post clips of my cool, stupid and glitchy MH Sunbreak and Wild Hearts hunts here just for fun. https://youtube.com/user/linkachu1000 <cite>Unsuprised_Pika posted [p:972041805] in How close ... [t:80372788]...</cite> <quote>Not remaking lush animated films in live action at all.</quote> ... Copied to Clipboard!
Prestoff 03/08/23 4:33:11 PM #5:	Bass_X0 posted... Wheres the middle that would make everybody happy? Making the movie good? --- DI MOLTO! <cite>Prestoff posted [p:972041807] in How close ... [t:80372788]...</cite> <quote>Bass_X0 posted... </cite><quote>Wheres the middle that would make everybody happy?</quote>Making the movie good?</quote> ... Copied to Clipboard!
BurmesePenguin 03/08/23 4:33:32 PM #6:	Bass_X0 posted... Make it completely new and different and people complain. I'll only complain if it's bad. See: Maleficent <cite>BurmesePenguin posted [p:972041812] in How close ... [t:80372788]...</cite> <quote>Bass_X0 posted... </cite><quote>Make it completely new and different and people complain.</quote>I'll only complain if it's bad.See: Maleficent</quote> ... Copied to Clipboard!
COVxy 03/08/23 4:35:14 PM #7:	Did people really complain about Beauty and the Beast? I thought it was great. Edit: yeah it got a 7.1 on imdb, which is pretty darn good. --- =E[(x-E[x])(y-E[y])] <cite>COVxy posted [p:972041847] in How close ... [t:80372788]...</cite> <quote>Did people really complain about Beauty and the Beast? I thought it was great.Edit: yeah it got a 7.1 on imdb, which is pretty darn good.</quote> ... Copied to Clipboard!
ZevLoveDOOM 03/08/23 4:36:04 PM #8:	how about not making any? the OGs were good enough as they were. leave them be... <cite>ZevLoveDOOM posted [p:972041864] in How close ... [t:80372788]...</cite> <quote>how about not making any?the OGs were good enough as they were. leave them be...</quote> ... Copied to Clipboard!
Jagr_68 03/08/23 4:38:19 PM #9:	Just don't do it. --- New York Rangers [2004-2008] https://media.giphy.com/media/WvQHBYW0q4TuxdAg61/giphy.gif https://psnprofiles.com/Jaromiroquai68 <cite>Jagr_68 posted [p:972041905] in How close ... [t:80372788]...</cite> <quote>Just don't do it.</quote> ... Copied to Clipboard!
bigblu89 03/08/23 4:43:40 PM #10:	Bass_X0 posted... Wheres the middle that would make everybody happy? There is no middle that would make everyone happy, about ANYTHING. --- It takes zero effort to be a good person. <cite>bigblu89 posted [p:972041985] in How close ... [t:80372788]...</cite> <quote>Bass_X0 posted... </cite><quote>Wheres the middle that would make everybody happy?</quote>There is no middle that would make everyone happy, about ANYTHING.</quote> ... Copied to Clipboard!
Supersex420 03/08/23 4:44:12 PM #11:	bigblu89 posted... There is no middle that would make everyone happy, about ANYTHING. Mostly wrong --- Oh- I sometimes make up all of my lines on the spot But I will always give what I got - KKB <cite>Supersex420 posted [p:972041992] in How close ... [t:80372788]...</cite> <quote>bigblu89 posted... </cite><quote>There is no middle that would make everyone happy, about ANYTHING.</quote>Mostly wrong</quote> ... Copied to Clipboard!
bigblu89 03/08/23 4:45:02 PM #12:	ZevLoveDOOM posted... how about not making any? the OGs were good enough as they were. leave them be... Funny thing is, most of the "OG" movies and shows that people love were remakes themselves. --- It takes zero effort to be a good person. <cite>bigblu89 posted [p:972042011] in How close ... [t:80372788]...</cite> <quote>ZevLoveDOOM posted... </cite><quote>how about not making any?the OGs were good enough as they were. leave them be...</quote>Funny thing is, most of the "OG" movies and shows that people love were remakes themselves.</quote> ... Copied to Clipboard!
bigblu89 03/08/23 4:45:28 PM #13:	Supersex420 posted... Mostly wrong Give me an example. --- It takes zero effort to be a good person. <cite>bigblu89 posted [p:972042020] in How close ... [t:80372788]...</cite> <quote>Supersex420 posted... </cite><quote>Mostly wrong</quote>Give me an example.</quote> ... Copied to Clipboard!
Questionmarktarius 03/08/23 4:45:54 PM #14:	When's the remake of Education for Death? <cite>Questionmarktarius posted [p:972042029] in How close ... [t:80372788]...</cite> <quote>When's the remake of Education for Death?</quote> ... Copied to Clipboard!
mehmeh1 03/08/23 4:46:42 PM #15:	COVxy posted... Did people really complain about Beauty and the Beast? I thought it was great. Edit: yeah it got a 7.1 on imdb, which is pretty darn good. Eeeh it's not BAD but it's still a soulless remake. Either way Lion King is still the worst since its existence is basically an insult to animation as a medium --- FC: 3840-6927-7945, have OR/Y/SM4SH/PSMD/S/US I'm a youtuber, here is my link: https://www.youtube.com/channel/UCRj1lj8EWzRtw3jp3HUXCxQ? .I play games <cite>mehmeh1 posted [p:972042037] in How close ... [t:80372788]...</cite> <quote>COVxy posted... </cite><quote>Did people really complain about Beauty and the Beast? I thought it was great.Edit: yeah it got a 7.1 on imdb, which is pretty darn good.</quote>Eeeh it's not BAD but it's still a soulless remake. Either way Lion King is still the worst since its existence is basically an insult to animation as a medium</quote> ... Copied to Clipboard!
Supersex420 03/08/23 4:48:02 PM #16:	bigblu89 posted... Give me an example. Your point --- Oh- I sometimes make up all of my lines on the spot But I will always give what I got - KKB <cite>Supersex420 posted [p:972042056] in How close ... [t:80372788]...</cite> <quote>bigblu89 posted... </cite><quote>Give me an example.</quote>Your point</quote> ... Copied to Clipboard!
Drumiester 03/08/23 4:49:28 PM #17:	Shot for shot doesn't bother me. I loved the Beauty and the Beast remake and really enjoyed Aladdin. It's when it's shot for shot AND done poorly (Lion King, Pinocchio, etc.) that I have issues. Or when Disney goes woke. --- I Love Sasha Banks/Mercedes Mone! CM Punk will return to All Elite Wrestling Currently Playing: Days Gone, NieR Automota <cite>Drumiester posted [p:972042079] in How close ... [t:80372788]...</cite> <quote>Shot for shot doesn't bother me. I loved the Beauty and the Beast remake and really enjoyed Aladdin.It's when it's shot for shot AND done poorly (Lion King, Pinocchio, etc.) that I have issues. Or when Disney goes woke.</quote> ... Copied to Clipboard!
bigblu89 03/08/23 4:50:43 PM #18:	COVxy posted... Did people really complain about Beauty and the Beast? I thought it was great. Edit: yeah it got a 7.1 on imdb, which is pretty darn good. Yeah, most complaints were that it was TOO much like the cartoon version. For example: We saw this before when it was called Beauty & the Beast. The songs we all heard before. Rather than an animated background you have a computer animated background but we have still seen it before. We sit down and pay to watch a movie we already saw turn live action and follow the same plot, the same game, as the movie we fell in love with oh so many years ago. We are living in an era for that, but we still want it to change at least a little. --- It takes zero effort to be a good person. <cite>bigblu89 posted [p:972042100] in How close ... [t:80372788]...</cite> <quote>COVxy posted... </cite><quote>Did people really complain about Beauty and the Beast? I thought it was great.Edit: yeah it got a 7.1 on imdb, which is pretty darn good.</quote>Yeah, most complaints were that it was TOO much like the cartoon version.For example:<quote>We saw this before when it was called Beauty & the Beast.The songs we all heard before. Rather than an animated background you have a computer animated background but we have still seen it before.We sit down and pay to watch a movie we already saw turn live action and follow the same plot, the same game, as the movie we fell in love with oh so many years ago.We are living in an era for that, but we still want it to change at least a little.</quote></quote> ... Copied to Clipboard!
Smiffwilm 03/08/23 4:51:10 PM #19:	Bass_X0 posted... Do an accurate shot for shot remake and people complain. Make it completely new and different and people complain. Wheres the middle that would make everybody happy? That's the problem. You're asking for something that is factually not possible. Ever. --- My Mario Maker 2 ID is 6RG-5XK-JCG <cite>Smiffwilm posted [p:972042109] in How close ... [t:80372788]...</cite> <quote>Bass_X0 posted... </cite><quote>Do an accurate shot for shot remake and people complain.Make it completely new and different and people complain.Wheres the middle that would make everybody happy?</quote>That's the problem. You're asking for something that is factually not possible. Ever.</quote> ... Copied to Clipboard!
pokedude900 03/08/23 4:52:08 PM #20:	Just stop remaking movies. Create something new. --- https://i.imgur.com/vuNZ2wj.jpg https://i.imgur.com/xitYdH6.jpg Come to the (un)official GameFAQs Touhou board. http://www.gamefaqs.com/boards/1110- <cite>pokedude900 posted [p:972042122] in How close ... [t:80372788]...</cite> <quote>Just stop remaking movies. Create something new.</quote> ... Copied to Clipboard!
Gobstoppers12 03/08/23 4:54:10 PM #21:	I don't fully understand the point of doing live action remakes at all, honestly, but if you're going to do them you should make them as close to the original as possible. --- I write Naruto Fanfiction. But I am definitely not a furry. <cite>Gobstoppers12 posted [p:972042163] in How close ... [t:80372788]...</cite> <quote>I don't fully understand the point of doing live action remakes at all, honestly, but if you're going to do them you should make them as close to the original as possible.</quote> ... Copied to Clipboard!
garan 03/08/23 4:58:17 PM #22:	ZevLoveDOOM posted... how about not making any? the OGs were good enough as they were. leave them be... This. Disney is artistically bankrupt. <cite>garan posted [p:972042255] in How close ... [t:80372788]...</cite> <quote>ZevLoveDOOM posted...</cite><quote>how about not making any?the OGs were good enough as they were. leave them be...</quote>This. Disney is artistically bankrupt.</quote> ... Copied to Clipboard!
bigblu89 03/08/23 5:23:22 PM #23:	garan posted... This. Disney is artistically bankrupt. I mean, they built their empire on unoriginal works, so what would make anyone think they would stop now? --- It takes zero effort to be a good person. <cite>bigblu89 posted [p:972042791] in How close ... [t:80372788]...</cite> <quote>garan posted... </cite><quote>This. Disney is artistically bankrupt.</quote>I mean, they built their empire on unoriginal works, so what would make anyone think they would stop now?</quote> ... Copied to Clipboard!
Collat 03/08/23 5:30:02 PM #24:	Bass_X0 posted... Wheres the middle that would make everybody happy? Making something original instead. <cite>Collat posted [p:972042911] in How close ... [t:80372788]...</cite> <quote>Bass_X0 posted... </cite><quote>Wheres the middle that would make everybody happy?</quote>Making something original instead. </quote> ... Copied to Clipboard!
pokedude900 03/08/23 5:30:30 PM #25:	They took existing stories and put their own personal spin on it. These remakes are just copy-pasting what they already did and making them worse. --- https://i.imgur.com/vuNZ2wj.jpg https://i.imgur.com/xitYdH6.jpg Come to the (un)official GameFAQs Touhou board. http://www.gamefaqs.com/boards/1110- <cite>pokedude900 posted [p:972042922] in How close ... [t:80372788]...</cite> <quote>They took existing stories and put their own personal spin on it. These remakes are just copy-pasting what they already did and making them worse.</quote> ... Copied to Clipboard!
garan 03/08/23 5:31:24 PM #26:	bigblu89 posted... I mean, they built their empire on unoriginal works, so what would make anyone think they would stop now? Also true. <cite>garan posted [p:972042935] in How close ... [t:80372788]...</cite> <quote>bigblu89 posted...</cite><quote>I mean, they built their empire on unoriginal works, so what would make anyone think they would stop now?</quote>Also true.</quote> ... Copied to Clipboard!
TheSavageDragon 03/08/23 5:35:43 PM #27:	Drumiester posted... Shot for shot doesn't bother me. I loved the Beauty and the Beast remake and really enjoyed Aladdin Both of those have scenes/songs added and/or removed. The most popular moments from the original are mostly shot for shot and that's pretty much it. <cite>TheSavageDragon posted [p:972043008] in How close ... [t:80372788]...</cite> <quote>Drumiester posted... </cite><quote>Shot for shot doesn't bother me. I loved the Beauty and the Beast remake and really enjoyed Aladdin</quote>Both of those have scenes/songs added and/or removed. The most popular moments from the original are mostly shot for shot and that's pretty much it.</quote> ... Copied to Clipboard!
RISEofCHRISTIAN 03/08/23 5:43:05 PM #28:	None of the Disney remakes have been shot for shot. --- Trump 2024 #magaa <cite>RISEofCHRISTIAN posted [p:972043137] in How close ... [t:80372788]...</cite> <quote>None of the Disney remakes have been shot for shot.</quote> ... Copied to Clipboard!
Jiek_Fafn 03/08/23 5:43:19 PM #29:	The rule of thumb is: Is it The Jungle Book? Yes>>it's acceptable to good No>>it's shit garbage --- I don't believe in belts. There should be no ranking system for toughness. <cite>Jiek_Fafn posted [p:972043144] in How close ... [t:80372788]...</cite> <quote>The rule of thumb is:Is it The Jungle Book?Yes>>it's acceptable to goodNo>>it's shit garbage</quote> ... Copied to Clipboard!
BurmesePenguin 03/08/23 6:57:41 PM #30:	Jiek_Fafn posted... The rule of thumb is: Is it The Jungle Book? Yes>>it's acceptable to good No>>it's shit garbage I heard Cinderella is also good. Which would make sense as both the Jungle Book and Cinderella animation Disney films are bad, so there's not much to ruin. <cite>BurmesePenguin posted [p:972044581] in How close ... [t:80372788]...</cite> <quote>Jiek_Fafn posted... </cite><quote>The rule of thumb is:Is it The Jungle Book?Yes>>it's acceptable to goodNo>>it's shit garbage</quote>I heard Cinderella is also good.Which would make sense as both the Jungle Book and Cinderella animation Disney films are bad, so there's not much to ruin. </quote> ... Copied to Clipboard!
Topic List	Page List: 1

Current Events > How close is too close for Disney remakes? (+) Yeah! (+)

Current Events > How close is too close for Disney remakes?