Current Events > Woulld Gollum have acted different in Return of the King if SPOILERS

Topic List	Page List: 1
Zikten 12/29/22 5:12:20 AM #1:	If Faramir had not captured Frodo, Sam and Gollum in Two Towers and Frodo had not let Faramir have his men rough up Gollum, would Gollum have stayed nice to Frodo and not sent Frodo to that spider, and later attacked Frodo at Mount Doom? In Two Towers he seemed to banish his evil personality, but then they met Faramir, and by the end of that interaction, Gollum was mad at Frodo <cite>Zikten posted [p:970476716] in Woulld Gol... [t:80293587]...</cite> <quote>If Faramir had not captured Frodo, Sam and Gollum in Two Towers and Frodo had not let Faramir have his men rough up Gollum, would Gollum have stayed nice to Frodo and not sent Frodo to that spider, and later attacked Frodo at Mount Doom?In Two Towers he seemed to banish his evil personality, but then they met Faramir, and by the end of that interaction, Gollum was mad at Frodo</quote> ... Copied to Clipboard!
ROBANN_88 12/29/22 5:15:04 AM #2:	Considering that none of the Faramir stuff happened in the book, but Gollum was still a dick, i think it made little difference --- Kremlin delenda est <cite>ROBANN_88 posted [p:970476729] in Woulld Gol... [t:80293587]...</cite> <quote>Considering that none of the Faramir stuff happened in the book, but Gollum was still a dick, i think it made little difference </quote> ... Copied to Clipboard!
rexcrk 12/29/22 5:16:47 AM #3:	ROBANN_88 posted... Considering that none of the Faramir stuff happened in the book No, that betrayal was part of the book. The Osgiliath stuff and Faramir desiring the Ring was not. --- Fate rarely calls on us at a moment of our choosing. <cite>rexcrk posted [p:970476739] in Woulld Gol... [t:80293587]...</cite> <quote>ROBANN_88 posted... </cite><quote>Considering that none of the Faramir stuff happened in the book</quote>No, that betrayal was part of the book. The Osgiliath stuff and Faramir desiring the Ring was not. </quote> ... Copied to Clipboard!
ROBANN_88 12/29/22 5:19:29 AM #4:	Oh, right. You're correct I completely misremembered how much they added in for the movie. Was the whole "Smeagol banishing Gollum" part in the book at all? Cause i always figured that when he said he'd 'serve the master of the precious' he was underhandedly talking about himself as its true master --- Kremlin delenda est <cite>ROBANN_88 posted [p:970476755] in Woulld Gol... [t:80293587]...</cite> <quote>Oh, right. You're correctI completely misremembered how much they added in for the movie. Was the whole "Smeagol banishing Gollum" part in the book at all?Cause i always figured that when he said he'd 'serve the master of the precious' he was underhandedly talking about himself as its true master</quote> ... Copied to Clipboard!
Topic List	Page List: 1