Final Fantasy X: 9.5
Final Fantasy XII: 4
Suikoden III: 9
Suikoden V: 8.5
Persona 3: 8.5 (P3P gets a 9.5)
Persona 4: 9.5
Shadow Hearts: 9
Shadow Hearts 2: 9
Disgaea: 7.5
I'm normally a harsh rater, but there are too many great games here!
--
SuperNiceDog won the Guru contest. Good job.