LogFAQs > #978965149

LurkerFAQs, Active Database ( 12.01.2023-present ), DB1, DB2, DB3, DB4, DB5, DB6, DB7, DB8, DB9, DB10, DB11, DB12, Clear

Topic List	Page List: 1
Topic	Trdl rates anything Magic the Gathering related
trdl23 02/21/24 1:26:37 PM #47:	TeamRocketElite posted... Blacker Lotus 48/100 I used to be bigger on this card, but adding to scarcity of a low-printed set has soured for me in the face of the reserved list in the modern era. It doesn't even have the memetic history of its fellow tear-me-up card from Unglued, Chaos Confetti. Sceptilesolar posted... Asmoranomardicadaistinaculdacar 95/100 There's a 0% chance you typed that without looking it up, and that alone makes me love this character. Her story is hilarious, all the flavor text associated with her even moreso -- especially when it's divorced from context of how and why she was compelled to make such bizarre dishes. In that sense I kind of wish I didn't know her story, which is why I can't give her a perfect score. Still, this is the charming goofiness I hope we can find more of in the future. Truly suffering from success. pjbasis posted... questing beast 30/100 Go ahead. See if you can recite all of Questing Beast's rules text from memory. I'll wait. A perfect encapsulation of the problems with FIRE design, even moreso than Oko (who was actually the product of a similar fuckup to Umezawa's Jitte, where they made a supposedly minor change late in development that they didn't get to test well). Plus, it's not even called "THE Questing Beast," leading to damn near everyone to forget it's both Legendary and a major player in Eldraine's culture. Once you parse it, it's not that complex nowadays as more and more abilities get slapped on cards for the purposes of slobbering over Commander, but it was still just a chore to see, read, and play against. Hbthebattle posted... Eight Fucking Bears 88/88 holy shit --- E come vivo? Vivo! <cite>trdl23 posted [p:978965149] in Trdl rates... [t:80701551]...</cite> <quote>TeamRocketElite posted... </cite><quote>Blacker Lotus</quote>48/100I used to be bigger on this card, but adding to scarcity of a low-printed set has soured for me in the face of the reserved list in the modern era. It doesn't even have the memetic history of its fellow tear-me-up card from Unglued, Chaos Confetti.Sceptilesolar posted... </cite><quote>Asmoranomardicadaistinaculdacar</quote>95/100There's a 0% chance you typed that without looking it up, and that alone makes me love this character. Her story is hilarious, all the flavor text associated with her even moreso -- especially when it's divorced from context of how and why she was compelled to make such bizarre dishes. In that sense I kind of wish I didn't know her story, which is why I can't give her a perfect score. Still, this is the charming goofiness I hope we can find more of in the future. Truly suffering from success.pjbasis posted... </cite><quote>questing beast</quote>30/100Go ahead. See if you can recite all of Questing Beast's rules text from memory. I'll wait.A perfect encapsulation of the problems with FIRE design, even moreso than Oko (who was actually the product of a similar fuckup to Umezawa's Jitte, where they made a supposedly minor change late in development that they didn't get to test well). Plus, it's not even called "THE Questing Beast," leading to damn near everyone to forget it's both Legendary and a major player in Eldraine's culture. Once you parse it, it's not that complex nowadays as more and more abilities get slapped on cards for the purposes of slobbering over Commander, but it was still just a chore to see, read, and play against.Hbthebattle posted... </cite><quote>Eight Fucking Bears</quote>88/88holy shit --- E come vivo? Vivo!</quote> ... Copied to Clipboard!
Topic List	Page List: 1