LogFAQs > #978831875

It happens often enough that I'd have to see a full list to narrow it down. Like I completely forgot Chirs Matthews existed.

Brandon Stokley had the most receiving yardage and the 1st TD (38 of his 52 yards came on that TD) of the Ravens first Super Bowl. He was one of their top receiving threats (probably only behind Ismail and Shannon Sharpe iirc) though, but it was on a run-first, low-scoring offense.

Jordy Nelson was a no-name receiver who had just 2 receiving TDs in each of his first 3 regular seasons and only had a career year with just 500-something receiving yards the year he went for 140 and a TD in their SB win.

Ricky Proehl had 71 and a TD for the Panthers against the Patriots (though he was just the 5th-leading receiver in that game).

Those are the first guys that came to mind for me, anyway.