Relieved that Carolyn was okay - I legit thought she was done, and so did she after Carson's "break up" comment set off alarm bells. He will tell her he needed her to react shocked, because...
Everyone knew Jaime had an idol, even though she didn't, and he didn't want her playing it. If Carolyn doesn't react naturally to those comments, Jaime plays it.
Yam-Yam was stupid to think he should turn on Carolyn now, because if he did that, he set up the very likely possibility of Jaime, Lauren, and Heidi teaming up against him and Carson. They would realize they had to work together to take out the two guys who were the biggest threats.
The "start over" thing at F5 is so dumb, and Jeff should know that now that this cast knew exactly what to expect after three seasons of it. Jeff also needs to realize that when you DM, you need to not run the same campaign over and over and over, because players figure you out. Change it up a little!
Heidi wasted her idol. Best move would've been to vote for Carolyn and play the idol on herself, thus eliminating Carolyn because the guys flip. Jaime gets safety for a rock draw and Carson and Yam-Yam would never be the only two drawing rocks.
Carolyn or Carson is winning this. I don't see Yam-Yam winning after tonight. We already knew Lauren and Heidi had zero shot.
---
Come check out my movie watchthrough topic: https://gamefaqs.gamespot.com/boards/8-gamefaqs-contests/80167031